WO1997039541A1

WO1997039541A1 - Transmit control system using control tone signalling

Info

Publication number: WO1997039541A1
Application number: PCT/US1997/005893
Authority: WO
Inventors: Steven Pfiefer; Donald R. Bauman; James K. Lyon
Original assignee: E.F. Johnson Company
Priority date: 1996-04-12
Filing date: 1997-04-11
Publication date: 1997-10-23
Also published as: AU2726397A; WO1997039535A2; WO1997039542A2; WO1997039543A2; WO1997039543A3; AU2726297A; AU2662997A; AU2450297A; WO1997039535A3; WO1997039542A3

Abstract

A transmit control system using in-band tones for activating and deactivating one or more remote sites. The transmit control system detects energy in two or more spectral regions to determine if the signal received is a harmonic signal or a signalling tone to prevent accidental deactivation of the transmitter system. In one application, a modified Goertzel algorithm is employed by a digital signal processor to provide tone detection and a two stage detection provides controlled switching in noisy environments.

Description

TRANSMIT CONTROL SYSTEM USING CONTROL TONE SIGNALLING

Eield of the Invention

The present invention relates generally to remote control using in-band signalling and in particular to transmit control and link control using in-band tone signalling in a distributed radio transmission system. Background of the Invention

There has been a growing interest in the use of repeater based systems for a variety of radio frequency communications. Advanced repeater systems must coordinate communications between a number of repeaters. The repeaters may be linked together using a variety of inter-repeater communications means. A remote subscriber, such as a mobile radio user, will request a channel to transmit information to other subscribers and other services connected to the repeater system. The repeater system manages the channels and provides a free channel to the calling subscriber.

However, such systems must orchestrate transmissions by each repeater. This is especially important in broadcast situations where a subscriber is communicating to a number of repeaters for rebroadcast to other subscribers in the system. It is inefficient to leave the repeater transmitters on when there is no information to transmit. Therefore, to service each subscriber rapidly, the transmitters should be activated in a reasonably short amount of time to prevent delays in access to the repeater system. Furthermore, it is desirable to activate the transmitters without supplying an additional control line to each repeater. Communications which are conducted over the repeater system must not be misinterpreted for control signals to the transmitters to ensure that the subscribers cannot accidentally disable the transmit control system. Therefore, there is a need in the art for a transmit control system which provides rapid activation of a number of transmitters. The transmit control system should use efficient control means to provide control to the separate transmitters. The transmit control system also should provide safeguard against accidental activation or deactivation of the transmitters in the system.

Summary ofthe Invention The present invention is a system for controlling one or more remote sites using an in-band signalling tone and a specialized detection system.

In one application, the remote sites include transmitters which are disabled when a signalling tone is received. Receipt of the signalling tone indicates that no transmissions by the central site are in progress. Once the signalling tone is extinguished, the transmitters are activated to broadcast information sent by the central site.

The detection system located at each remote site monitors energy residing in the spectral region assigned to one or more in-band signalling tones. If a signal is detected in this spectral region, then energy in another spectral region is measured to determine if the signals are signalling tones or harmonics of voice or data information being transmitted by the system. If the energy in the data and voice portions of the spectrum is relatively low, then the system is receiving a signalling tone, and the transmitters are disabled.

One embodiment ofthe present transmit control system monitors data transmissions made by the repeater system to determine whether the signal received in the spectral range ofthe signalling tone is actually a signalling tone or harmonic noise.

One embodiment of the present transmit control system monitors signals in the voice band of interest to verify the signal received in the spectral range of the signalling tone. Brief Description of the Drawings

In the drawings, where like numerals describe like components throughout the several views:

Figure 1 is a block diagram showing one environment in which the present transmit control system may be practiced: Figure 2 is one example of a transmit control module according to one embodiment of the present invention; Figure 3 is one example of a link control module according to one embodiment of the present invention;

Figure 4 is a flow chart of the operation of one embodiment of a central site control system; Figure 5 is a flow chart ofthe operation of one embodiment of a remote site control system;

Figure 6 shows a link state diagram, according to one embodiment ofthe present invention;

Figure 7 shows a transmit state diagram, according to one embodiment of the present invention;

Figure 8 shows a transmit state diagram, according to one embodiment of the present invention;

Figure 9 is a timing diagram showing the operation of one embodiment of the present transmit control system; Figure 10 is a timing diagram showing one embodiment of a two stage detection system;

Figure 11 is an example of the operation of one application of the present transmit control system;

Figure 12 is one example of an in-band tone detection system according to one embodiment ofthe present transmit control system;

Figure 13 is one example ofthe audio portion ofthe central site controller according to one embodiment ofthe present invention; and

Figure 14 is one example ofthe audio portion ofthe remote site controller according to one embodiment of the present invention. Detailed Description

In the following detailed description ofthe preferred embodiment, references are made to the accompanying drawings which form a part hereof, and in which is shown by way of illustration specific embodiments in which the invention may be practiced. These embodiments are described in sufficient detail to enable those skilled in the art to practice the invention, and it is to be understood that other embodiments may be utilized and that structural changes may be made without departing from the spirit and scope ofthe present invention. The following detailed description is, therefore, not to be taken in a limiting sense, and the scope of the present invention is defined by the appended claims and equivalents thereof. One environment in which the present transmit control system may be practiced is shown in Figure 1. The present transmit control system is demonstrated in this environment, however, this example is not intended to be exclusive or limiting, and other applications and environments exist which do not depart from the scope and spirit ofthe present invention. Central site 1 10 controls the transmissions emanating from remote sites

A-N. For instance, in one embodiment the central site 1 10 enables transmissions from remote sites A-N when central site 110 has information to send, and disables transmissions when central site 110 does not have information to send. In one embodiment links 120A-N are digital Tl links. In another embodiment links 120 A-N are line of sight optical links. Other types of links may be used without departing from the scope and spirit ofthe present invention.

In trunked mobile radio systems the remote sites A-N are remote repeaters which receive information from central site 1 10 and retransmit the information to a plurality of (mobile) subscriber units (not shown). Such systems often transmit voice signals and data signals between the subscriber units and the remote sites. In one such system, the transmissions include audio (300 Hz to 3 KHz) plus supervisory tone data, audio (300 Hz to 3 KHz) plus low speed (3.0 to 3.3 KHz) data which may be shifted upband, and high speed data (300 Hz to 3 KHz). In such systems it is desirable to control the remote site transmissions with a minimal amount of disruption to the communications between the subscriber units and the remote sites. This means that the remote sites A-N must detect signals from the central site 1 10 in a relatively short amount of time so that the subscriber units can access the remote sites. In-Band Tone Transmit Control In one embodiment an in-band tone control is used by the central site 1 10 to control the remote sites A-N. The presence or absence of an in-band tone generated by the control site 1 10 is detected at the remote sites A-N. For the tone not to interfere with call information, such as in-band voice or data, the tone should not be present during a call. In one embodiment, a tone is transmitted by the central site when the central site 1 10 has no information to broadcast over the remote sites A-N. When the tone is absent the central site 1 10 has information to transmit to the remote sites. This embodiment also has the advantage of working with any link, since the tone is in-band, and the tone generation and detection modules are independent ofthe link.

The use of an in-band tone control introduces the false signalling and the signal blocking effects. False signalling is a condition where the detection module erroneously detects a signal which is not the in-band transmit control tone. Signal blocking is the condition where the detection module fails to detect the in-band transmit control tone due to interference with other information transmitted over the link. Both effects are competing, since as the sensitivity of the detection module is increased the likelihood of signal blocking diminishes, but the false signalling likelihood increases. Also if the detection module sensitivity decreases, then the false signalling effect is decreased and the signal blocking effect increases. Therefore, the present in-band tone control system must provide features to balance the false signalling and signal blocking effects. The present control system decreases signal blocking by using an in-band tone in a frequency portion which is not within the high energy portion ofthe voice spectrum. Most of voice energy lies between 500 to 700 Hz with harmonics falling off in frequency. Some link systems do not transmit the lower frequency ranges (such as 0-300 Hz), therefore one embodiment of the present system uses a 2600 Hz tone. Other tones may be used, provided they are not within the statistically high energy portion ofthe transmissions and the tones arc within the bandpass range of the link. False signalling is reduced since the detection module detects the control tone and then investigates energy in other spectral portions to ensure that the detected tone is not a harmonic (or subharmonic) of the audio signals transmitted over the link (in this example, voice signals).

For example, if the 2600 Hz tone is detected and substantial energy is detected in the 1300 Hz and 650 Hz spectral portions, then it is likely that the 2600 Hz signal is really voice or data energy. If the energy detected in the 1300 Hz and 650 Hz spectral portions is relatively minor, then it is likely that the 2600 Hz tone is the control tone and not voice or data energy.

Another check is to compare the energy in the 2600 Hz frequency range with the energy found in the remaining portion ofthe link passband to determine if the 2600 Hz signal is truly the control signal. In one embodiment this is achieved using a notch passband filter to detect the 2600 Hz signal and a notch stopband filter to detect the remaining spectral range.

This embodiment of the present transmit control system monitors energy in the spectral region of the control tone and absence of energy in other spectral regions to determine whether the control signal is present. Figure 2 shows the inputs and outputs for one embodiment ofthe in-band tone transmit control module. The permutations for this embodiment are provided in Table I.

TABLE I. Transmit Control Inputs and Outputs

Control Tone Transmit

Call State Spectral Region Other Spectral Regions State absent signal detected no signals detected disabled absent signal detected signals detected (abnormal) enabled present no signal detected no signals detected enabled present no signal detected signals detected (normal) enabled

As shown in Table I, in the case where only the control tone is detected the transmissions from the remote site are disabled. Otherwise, they are enabled. The second state is abnormal, since signals are detected despite the absence of call information. One consequence ofthe present system is that if the link is broken for any reason the remote sites are enabled, since the control tone from the central site is disabled with the link. Alternate embodiments incoφorate link information into the transmit control module from the link control module (described below) to control the transmit state in the event that a link fails.

Other energy comparisons may be performed without departing from the scope and spirit of the present invention, and the examples provided herein are not intended to be exclusive or limiting. For example, in environments where low speed data signals are transmitted by the system, the data frequency range may be used as the "other spectral region" energy to detect whether a call is being handled by the system.

Figure 4 shows tone generation at the central site 1 10 according to one embodiment of the present invention. After a power on ofthe system the tone generator is enabled 410 and the call state ofthe system is set to idle 420. If a subscriber unit is requesting a transmission then the central site 1 10 deactivates the tone generator 440 and sets the call state to transmitting 450. If no transmission was requested by the subscriber unit 460 the call state remains idle and the central site continues looping until a transmission is requested. After a transmission has been initiated the tone is inhibited during the call 495 and until the transmission is done 480, 490.

Figure 5 shows one embodiment of the transmit control system wherein data is used as the "other spectral region" signal. After power on the transmitter is automatically disabled and the call state is set to idle 505. If a tone is detected 510 but there is no other wideband energy (a data signal in this example) 515 then the state remains idle and the tone indicates no transmission. Once the tone is absent or a data signal is detected 520 the transmitter is enabled 526 and the call state is changed to transmitting 528. The system remains in this state until a tone is again detected 532 and no transmission energy (data energy, in this example) is detected 534. Upon receipt of a tone and no other data the transmitter is disabled 542 and the call state reverts to idle 544. It should be noted that the data energy of this example could be substituted with any other signal energy, such as voice band energy, as long as it is not the tone energy, without departing from the scope and spirit ofthe present invention.

In trunked radio applications it is desired that the transmit control function perform so that the subscriber unit handshake time is not increased by more than approximately 50 milliseconds. Other applications may allow for shorter or longer latency periods. In-Band Tone Link Control

The link control module provides information as to whether the link is up or down. The link control module also provides a signal to an alarm module for failure alarm purposes.

In one embodiment the link control module detects wideband energy, which is any energy within the passband ofthe link. When a call is not present, the wideband energy is energy from the signalling tone and when a call is present it is low-speed data energy (provided the system transmits low speed data during calls). The link is determined to be "up" whenever there is wideband energy and "down" if there is no wideband energy.

Figure 3 shows one embodiment where signals representing energy in the spectral vicinity of the control tone and energy in the data spectral region are logically "ORed" to indicate wideband energy. This embodiment uses the control tone energy and data energy signals used by the transmit control module, and is an example of an alternate system for link control. Again, the link is determined to be "up" whenever there is wideband energy and "down" if there is no wideband energy.

Alternate embodiments provide link control using parameters independent ofthe transmit control parameters.

Measurement of wideband energy is relatively straightforward for a continuous tone, however for data signals, the measurement may fluctuate. To prevent oscillation of the link control signal in one embodiment the wideband energy is monitored over the interval of approximately one second to determine if wideband energy is present. Other times may be used so long as the link control signal is not substantially delayed. Figure 6 shows one embodiment in which the link is "up" as long as the wideband energy is present, and "down" when it is absent.

Figure 7 shows a transmit control state diagram according to one embodiment ofthe present system which incorporates tone infoπnation and link information into enabling or disabling the transmitter. Figure 8 shows an alternate embodiment which incorporates wideband energy as well as tone and link information.

Figure 9 shows signals in one embodiment ofthe present invention and demonstrates the transmit control and link control of this embodiment. Traces A and B demonstrate that the tone signal is inhibited when transmissions from the central site 1 10 are being performed. Trace C illustrates how the system functions during a link malfunction. The central site 1 10 data (trace D) and voice (trace E) are transmitted to the remote site when the remote site tone is inhibited (trace E). The data and voice information received by the remote site is as good as the link quality (traces G and H). The remote site wideband energy, trace 1, is the logical OR ofthe remote site tone (F) and remote site data (G) (for purposes of this example, the data and voice transmissions are overlapping in time, yet this may differ in other systems. In those systems the wideband energy would have to be the logical OR of traces F, G, and H.)

Traces J and K demonstrate the effect ofthe averaging ofthe remote wideband energy signal (I) to avoid needless drops in the link and unnecessary keying and unkeying ofthe remote site transmitter.

Tone Detection System In one embodiment the tone detection is provided by a bandpass filter, rectifier, low pass filter, and threshold comparison. The bandpass filter output and the low pass filter output are compared to determine whether the tone is present and the other transmissions are absent.

Another embodiment incoφorates a digital signal processor (DSP) executing a Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) to detect the tone, since a single tone is used to inhibit the transmissions. A Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) calculates the entire spectrum for N samples and involved N log N complex computations. The DFT only requires N² complex computations generally. But for a single frequency, it requires only N complex computations.

Another embodiment uses a modification of a Goertzel algorithm executing on a DSP, followed by direct threshold comparison, to perform a time to frequency transformation of the input signal and compare the tone frequency with other frequencies in the signal. This provides an efficient spectral comparison ofthe elements of the signal arriving from the central site 1 10. The modified Goertzel algorithm is described in the book entitled "Digital Signal Processing Applications", Volume 1 of 2, by Analog Devices, Inc. 1992. The modified Goertzel algorithm is described in detail in pages 457 to 465. This method involves a repeated operation of a feedback method and a feedforward method, which is used to generate a result indicating the energy present in a spectral region of interest. The modified Goertzel algorithm simplifies calculations by the DSP and increase the efficiency and speed ofthe tone detection. This system squares all terms and computes the magnitude squared of the frequency of interest, which reduces each complex coefficient of the calculation to a single real coefficient. The single real coefficient may be used to calculate every term of the summation. This system also operates on samples as they are input into the system which increases throughput of the DSP.

Figure 10 shows the benefits of signal filtering ofthe transmitter signal to prevent short toggling ofthe transmitter at the remote site (traces A-D). The input signal (A) is compared to generate an absence signal (B). The absence signal is integrated (C) and digitized (D) to produce the switching signal shown in trace D. The process creates a low frequency representation of the input signal to prevent toggling the output signal for minor variations in the input signal. An integration of trace E is shown in Figure F, which is then digitized to produce trace G. The averaging method creates an energy/tone detection which is substantially independent of the actual tone level. Figure 11 demonstrates one example of a transmit control system.

Assuming that the system is not transmitting, a control signal of 2600 Hz is transmitted to the repealer by the central site to indicate an inactive transmission state. The subscriber unit requests a channel for transmission from its local repeater. Information about the subscriber unit's request is transmitted by the repeater to the channel controller at the central site over the link. II^" the controller verifies that the channel is free, the channel controller terminates the control signal. The repeater detects the loss of the control signal and activates the transmitter. The central controller then transmits control and voice information to the repeater for rebroadcast by the repeater.

Figure 12 shows one embodiment of a DSP system for control signal detection. DSP 56002 executes the modified Goertzel algorithm and detects the tone transmission from the central controller. Data signals are monitored as the second source of spectral information and are used in the control systems shown in Figure 5 and described above. Further details of the audio block diagram are provided in Figures 13 and 14, at the central controller site and remote site, respectively.

Claims

WHAT IS CLAIMED IS:

1. A method for transmit control in a repeater system, comprising the step of if signals from a different spectral region are substantially absent, disabling a transmitter at a remote site.

2. The method of claim 1 , wherein the step of disabling comprises the step of if a control tone is detected and if signals from a different spectral region are substantially absent, disabling a transmitter at a remote site.

3. The method of claim 2, further comprising the steps of: transmitting an in-band tone of frequency F as the control tone when a central site has no information to transmit over one or more remote sites, and inhibiting the in-band tone when the central site has information to transmit over the one or more remote sites.

4. The method of claim 3, further comprising the steps of: at each ofthe one or more remote sites, controlling a transmitter, by the steps including: analog to digital converting the in-band tone to create a digitized in-band tone; detecting the digitized in-band tone using a processor; if the in-band tone is detected and if measured signals from a different spectral region are substantially absent, disabling a transmitter at the remote site; and if no in-band tone is detected, activating the transmitter.

5. The method of claim 1 , wherein the different spectral region is a data spectral region.

6. The method of claim 1 , wherein the different spectral region is a voice spectral region.

7. The method of claim 2, wherein the step of detecting comprises the step of using a modified Goertzel measurement system to detect the control tone.

8. The method of claim 3, wherein the step of transmitting further comprises the step of transmitting a 2600 Hz in-band tone.

9. The method of claim 2, wherein the control tone is at a frequency which does not overlap with data and voice transmissions.

10. A method for transmit control in a repeater system, comprising the steps of: analog to digital converting an in-band tone to create a digitized in-band tone; detecting the digitized in-band tone using a processor, the in-band tone transmitted by a central site when the central site has no information to transmit over one or more remote sites and the in-band tone inhibited when the central site has information to transmit over the one or more remote sites; if the in-band tone is detected, measuring signals from a different spectral region, if signals from the different spectral region are substantially absent, then disabling a transmitter at a remote site; and if no in-band tone is detected, activating the transmitter.

1 1 . The method of claim 10, wherein the different spectral region is a data spectral region.

12. The method of claim 10, wherein the different spectral region is a voice spectral region.

13. The method of claim 30, wherein the step of detecting comprises the step of using a modified Goertzel measurement system to detect the in-band tone.

14. The method of claim 10, wherein the in-band tone is a 2600 Hz in-band tone.

15. A transmit control system, comprising: a signal detector for detecting signals from a defined spectral area.

16. The transmit control system of claim 14, further comprising: a tone detector for detecting a control tone.

17. The transmit control system of claim 15, further comprising: a control tone generator for generating a control tone when a central site has no information to transmit, wherein the tone detector includes: an analog to digital convertor for converting signals in a spectral vicinity ofthe control tone; and a processor, located at a remote site, for detecting a control tone from samples generated by the analog to digital convertor.

18. The system of claim 16, further comprising a transmission inhibitor for disabling a transmitter at the remote site if a control tone is detected and energy in a different spectral region is not detected.

19. The system of claim 16, wherein the processor executes a modified Goertzel algorithm for detecting a control tone signal.

20. The system of claim 16, wherein the control tone generator generates a 2600 Hz tone.

21. The system of claim 16, wherein the signals from a different spectral area comprise data signals transmitted by the central site.

22. The system of claim 16, further comprising a controller for inhibiting transmissions when a control tone is detected and signals from another spectral region are substantially absent.

23. A method of link control, comprising the step of: if a control tone is detected, signalling an active link.

24. The method of claim 24, further comprising the step of: if wideband spectral energy is substantially absent, then signalling an inactive link.