Search Images Maps Play YouTube News Gmail Drive More »
Sign in
Screen reader users: click this link for accessible mode. Accessible mode has the same essential features but works better with your reader.

Patents

  1. Advanced Patent Search
Publication numberUSRE43324 E1
Publication typeGrant
Application numberUS 11/509,549
Publication date24 Apr 2012
Filing date24 Aug 2006
Priority date26 Sep 1996
Also published asCA2215481A1, DE69712583D1, DE69712583T2, EP0833489A2, EP0833489A3, EP0833489B1, US6404857, US6757361, US20030129986, USRE40634, USRE41534, USRE41608, USRE43183, USRE43255
Publication number11509549, 509549, US RE43324 E1, US RE43324E1, US-E1-RE43324, USRE43324 E1, USRE43324E1
InventorsChristopher Douglas Blair, Roger Louis Keenan
Original AssigneeVerint Americas, Inc.
Export CitationBiBTeX, EndNote, RefMan
External Links: USPTO, USPTO Assignment, Espacenet
VOIP voice interaction monitor
US RE43324 E1
Abstract
A signal monitoring apparatus and method involving devices for monitoring signals representing communications traffic, devices for identifying at least one predetermined parameter by analyzing the context of the at least one monitoring signal, a device for recording the occurrence of the identified parameter, a device for identifying the traffic stream associated with the identified parameter, a device for analyzing the recorded data relating to the occurrence, and a device, responsive to the analysis of the recorded data, for controlling the handling of communications traffic within the apparatus.
Images(5)
Previous page
Next page
Claims(39)
1. A signal monitoring system for monitoring and analyzing communications passing through a monitoring point, the system comprising:
a digital voice recorder (18) for monitoring two-way conversation traffic streams passing through the monitoring point, said digital voice recorder having connections (20) for being operatively attached to the monitoring point;
a digital processor (30) connected to said digital voice recorder for identifying at least one predetermined parameter by analyzing the voice communication content of at least one monitored signal taken from the traffic streams;
a recorder (38) attached to said digital processor for recording occurrences of the predetermined parameter;
a traffic stream identifier (36) for identifying the traffic stream associated with the predetermined parameter;
a data analyzer (36) connected to said digital processor for analyzing the recorded data relating to the occurrences; and
a communication traffic controller (34) operatively connected to said data analyzer and, operating responsive to the analysis of the recorded data, for controlling the handling of communications traffic within said monitoring system.
2. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said at least one predetermined parameter includes a frequency of keywords identified in the voice communication content of the at least one monitored signal.
3. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said digital processor further identifies episodes of anger or shouting by analyzing amplitude envelope.
4. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said at least one predetermined parameter is a prosody of the voice communication content of the at least one monitored signal.
5. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said connections for being operatively attached to the telephony exchange switch are attached via high impedance taps (20) to telephone signal lines (24, 26) attached to said telephony exchange switch.
6. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said communication traffic controller serves to identify at least one section of traffic relative to another so as to identify a source of the predetermined parameter.
7. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said communication traffic controller serves to influence further monitoring actions within the apparatus.
8. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein the analyzed contents of the at least one monitored signal comprise the interaction between at least two signals representing an at least two-way conversation.
9. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein the recorder operates in real time to provide a real-time indication of the occurrence.
10. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said digital voice recorder comprises an analog/digital convertor (18) for converting analog voice into a digital signal.
11. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said digital processor is a Digital Signal Processor (30) arranged to operate in accordance with an analyzing algorithm.
12. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein the digital processor is arranged to operate in real time.
13. The monitoring system of claim 1, further comprising a replay station (32) connected to said digital processor and arranged such that the voice communication content of the at least one monitored signal can be recorded and monitored by said digital processor for identifying the at least one parameter at some later time.
14. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein the at least one predetermined parameter comprises plural predetermined parameters and wherein said recorder records the occurrence of the plural predetermined parameters in each of the two directions of traffic separately.
15. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said traffic stream identifier comprises a means for receiving an identifier tagged onto the traffic so as to identify its source.
16. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said digital voice recorder for monitoring the traffic streams is operative responsive to an output from said traffic stream identifier identifying the source of the conversation in which the predetermined parameter has been identified, or a threshold occurrence of the predetermined parameter has been exceeded.
17. The monitoring system of claim 1, wherein said digital voice recorder, said digital processor, said recorder, said traffic stream identifier, and said data analyzer reside on an add-in card to a telecommunications system.
18. A method for capturing a telephone interaction, comprising:
receiving audio data packets at a switch that are transmitted over a first network, wherein the audio data packets include packet headers and packet bodies;
identifying data within the audio data packets at a data analysis engine that is communicatively connected to the switch by a second network, the identifying being based on at least one predetermined parameter associated with a payload of the audio data packets; and
recording for analysis, at a recorder, any of the received audio data packets that include the at least one predetermined parameter, wherein the recorder is communicatively connected to the data analysis engine by the second network.
19. The method of claim 18, wherein the selecting step includes identifying the traffic stream in which a particular audio data packet belongs.
20. The method of claim 18, wherein the identifying includes analyzing a packet header within the audio data packets based on a channel number, a time stamp and a data format included within the packet header.
21. The method of claim 18, wherein identifying includes analyzing a packet body within the audio data packets.
22. The method of claim 18, wherein said receiving step is active or passive.
23. The method of claim 18, further comprising analyzing, at the data analysis engine, a packet body within the audio data packets to identify voice communication content included in the audio data packets.
24. The method of claim 23, wherein identifying voice communication content includes identifying a frequency of keywords identified in the audio data packets received over the first network.
25. The method of claim 23, wherein identifying voice communication content includes identifying episodes of anger or shouting based upon an amplitude envelope associated with the audio data packets.
26. The method of claim 23, wherein identifying voice communication content includes identifying a prosody associated with the voice communication content of the audio data packets.
27. The method of claim 23, wherein the step of storing is based upon identification of voice communication content that includes a predetermined parameter.
28. The method of claim 23, wherein identifying voice communication content includes examining incoming and outgoing traffic streams to identify whether a talk-over condition exists with respect to the audio data packets.
29. The method of claim 23, wherein identifying voice communication content includes identifying whether one or more of a predetermined group of words exists with respect to the audio data packets.
30. The method of claim 23, wherein identifying voice communication content includes identifying stress voice content associated with the audio data packets.
31. The method of claim 30, wherein stress is identified by determining changes in volume, speed and tone of voice content associated with the audio data packets.
32. The method of claim 23, wherein identifying voice communication content includes identifying a delay between data packet transmissions in opposite directions.
33. A recording and analysis system, comprising:
a monitoring interface operable to receive audio data packets transmitted on a computer network, the audio data packets including a packet header and a packet body, and being associated with a two-way voice interaction;
a data analysis engine operable to analyze data from selected audio data packets, including analyzing the packet header by analyzing a channel number, a time stamp and a data format within the packet header, and analyzing the packet body; and
a storage device operable to capture at least a portion of the audio data packets responsive to the analysis module.
34. The system of claim 33, wherein the data analysis engine is configured to select audio data packets based upon predefined information.
35. The system of claim 34, wherein the data analysis engine determines which of a plurality of voice interactions to which a selected audio data packet belongs.
36. The system of claim 33, wherein the monitoring interface is an active interface or a passive interface.
37. The system of claim 33, wherein the storage device is further operable to sort the audio data packets in accordance with a timestamp.
38. The system of claim 33, wherein the data analysis engine is configured to analyze voice communication content associated with packet bodies of the audio data packets.
39. A recording system for capturing and recording audio data packets transmitted across a data network, comprising:
a data switch operable to receive a plurality of call setup requests, requesting to establish a voice data session between a calling party and a called party, the voice data session comprising audio data packets communicated between a calling party and a called party via a data network;
a monitoring device operable to capture the audio data packets received by the data switch, wherein the monitor is operable to identify a call to which the audio data packets belong, and to associate the audio data packets to a voice interaction session; and
a data store operable to interface with the monitor and to record at least a portion of the received audio data packets to a record associated with the voice interaction session.
Description

Notice: More than one reissue application has been filed for the reissue of U.S. Pat. No. 6,757,361. The reissue applications are: “Voice Interaction Analysis Module,” Ser. No. 11/509,553, filed on Aug. 24, 2006; “Machine Learning Based Upon Feedback From Contact Center Analysis,” Ser. No. 11/509,550, filed on Aug. 24, 2006; “Distributed Analysis of Voice Interaction Data,” Ser. No. 11/509,554, filed on Aug. 24, 2006; “Distributed Recording of Voice Interaction Data,” Ser. No. 11/509,552, filed on Aug. 24, 2006; “VoIP Voice Interaction Monitor” (the present application), Ser. No. 11/509,549, filed on Aug. 24, 2006; and, “VoIP Interaction Recorder,” Ser. No. 11/509,551, filed on Aug. 24, 2006, and, “Communication Management System for Network-Based Telephones,” filed on Oct. 18, 2006, all of which are divisional reissues of “Signal Monitoring Apparatus Analyzing Voice Communication Content,” Ser. No. 11/477,124, filed on Jun. 28, 2006, which is a broadening reissue of U.S. Pat. No. 6,757,361, issued on Jun. 29, 2004. Ser. No. 11/583,381, filed on Oct. 19, 2006, is a reissue of U.S. Pat. No. 6,757,361.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to signal monitoring apparatus and in particular, but riot exclusively to telecommunications monitoring apparatus which may be arranged for monitoring a plurality of telephone conversations.

DESCRIPTION OF THE RELATED ART

Telecommunications networks are increasingly being used for the access of information and for carrying out commercial and/or financial transactions. In order to safeguard such use of the networks, it has become appropriate to record the two-way telecommunications traffic, whether voice traffic or data traffic, that arises as such transactions are carried out. The recording of such traffic is intended particularly to safeguard against abusive and fraudulent use of the telecommunications network for such purposes.

More recently, so-called “call-centers” have been established at which operative personnel are established to deal with enquiries and transactions required of the commercial entity having established the call-center. An example of the increasing use of such call-centers is the increasing use of “telephone banking” services and the telephone ordering of retail goods.

Although the telecommunications traffic handled by such call-centers is monitored in an attempt to preserve the integrity of the call-centre, the manner in which such communications networks, and their related call-centers, are monitored are disadvantageously limited having regard to the data/information that can be provided concerning the traffic arising in association with the call-center.

For example, in large call-centers, it is difficult for supervisors to establish with any confidence that they have accurately, and effectively, monitored the quality of all their staff's work so as to establish, for example, how well their staff are handling customers' enquiries and/or transaction requirements, or how well their staff are seeking to market/publicise a particular product etc.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention seeks to provide for telecommunications monitoring apparatus having advantages over known such apparatus.

According to one aspect of the present invention there is provided signal monitoring apparatus comprising:

    • means for monitoring signals representing communications traffic;
    • means for identifying at least one predetermined parameter by analysing the content of at least one monitored signal;
    • means for recording the occurrence of the identified parameter;
    • means for identifying the traffic stream associated with the identified parameter;
    • means for analysing the recorded data relating to the said occurrence; and
    • means, responsive to the analysis of the said recorded data, for controlling the handling of communications traffic within the apparatus.

Preferably, the means for controlling the handling of the communications traffic serves to identify at least one section of traffic relative to another.

Also, the means for controlling may serve to influence further monitoring actions within the apparatus.

Advantageously, the analysed contents of the at least one signal comprise the interaction between at least two signals of traffic representing an at least two-way conversation. In particular, the at least two interacting signals relate to portions of interruption or stiltedness within the traffic.

Preferably, the means for monitoring signals can include means for recording signals.

Preferably, the means for recording the occurrence of the parameter comprises means for providing, in real time, a possibly instantaneous indication of said occurrence, and/or comprises means for storing, permanently or otherwise, information relating to said occurrence.

Dependent upon the particular parameter, or parameters, relevant to a call-center provider, the present invention advantageously allows for the improved monitoring of traffic so as to identify which one(s) of a possible plurality of data or voice interactions might warrant further investigation whilst also allowing for statistical trends to be recorded and analysed.

The apparatus is advantageously arranged for monitoring speech signals and indeed any form of telecommunication traffic.

For example, by analysing a range of parameters of the signals representing traffic such as speech, data or video, patterns, trends and anomalies within a plurality of interactions can be readily identified and these can then be used for example, to influence future automated analysis, and rank or grade the conversations and/or highlight conversations likely to be worthy of detailed investigation or playback by the call-center provider. The means for monitoring the telecommunications signals may be advantageously arranged to monitor a plurality of separate two-way voice, data or video conversations, and this makes the apparatus particularly advantageous for use within a call-centre.

The means for monitoring the telecommunications signals advantageously arranged to monitor the signals digitally by any one variety of appropriate means which typically involve the use of high impedance taps into the network and which have little, or no, effect on the actual network.

It should of course be appreciated that the invention can be arranged for monitoring telecommunications signals transmitted over any appropriate medium, for example a hardwired network comprising twisted pair or co-axial lines or indeed a telecommunications medium employing radio waves.

In cases where the monitored signal is not already in digital form, the apparatus can advantageously include analogue/digital conversion means for operating on the signal produced by the aforesaid means for monitoring the telecommunications signals.

It should also be appreciated that the present invention can comprise means for achieving passive monitoring of a telecommunications network or call-centre etc.

The means for identifying the at least one predetermined parameter advantageously includes a Digital Signal Processor which can be arranged to operate in accordance with any appropriate algorithm. Preferably, the signal processing required by the means for identifying the at least one parameter can advantageously be arranged to be provided by spare capacity arising in the Digital Signal Processors found within the apparatus and primarily arranged for controlling the monitoring, compression and/or recording of signals.

As mentioned above, the particular parameters arranged to be identified by the apparatus can be selected from those that are considered appropriate to the requirements of, for example, the call-centre provider.

However, for further illustration, the following is a non-exhaustive list of parameters that could be identified in accordance with the present invention and assuming that the telecommunications traffic concerned comprises a plurality of two-way telephone interactions such as conversations:

    • non-voice elements within predominantly voice-related interactions for example dialling, Interactive Voice Response Systems, and recorded speech such as interactive voice response prompts, computer synthesized speech or background noise such as line noise;
    • the relationship between transmissions in each direction, for example the delay occurring, or the overlap between, transmissions in opposite directions;
    • the amplitude envelope of the signals, so as to determine caller anger or episodes of shouting;
    • the frequency spectrum of the signal in various frequency bands;
    • advanced parameters characterizing the actual speaker which may advantageously be used in speech authentication;
    • measures of the speed of interaction, for example for determining the ratio of word to inter-word pauses;
    • the language used by the speaker(s);
    • the sex of the speaker(s);
    • the presence or absence of particular words, for example word spotting using advanced speech recognition techniques;
    • the frequency and content of prosody including pauses, repetitions, stutters and nonsensical utterances in the conversation;
    • vibration or tremor within a voice; and
    • the confidence/accuracy with which words are recognized by the receiving party to the conversation so as to advantageously identify changes in speech patterns arising from a caller.

Parameters such as the following, and having no direct relationship to each call's content, can also be monitored:

    • date, time, duration and direction of call:
    • externally generated “tagging” information for transferred calls or calls to particular customers;

As will be appreciated, the importance of each of the above parameters and the way in which they can be combined to highlight particular good, or bad, caller interactions can be readily defined by the call-center provider.

Advantageously, the apparatus can be arranged so as to afford each of the parameters concerned a particular weighting, or relative value.

The apparatus may of course also be arranged to identify the nature of the data monitored, for example whether speech, facsimile, modem or video etc. and the rate at which the signals are monitored can also be recorded and adjusted within the apparatus.

According to a further feature of the invention, the means for identifying the at least one parameter can be arranged to operate in real time or, alternatively, the telecommunications signals can be recorded so as to be monitored by the means for identifying at least one parameter at some later stage.

Advantageously, the means for recording the actual occurrence of the identified parameter(s) can be arranged to identify an absolute value for such occurrences within the communications network and/or call-centre as a whole or, alternatively, the aforementioned recording can be carried out on a per-conversation or a per-caller/operative basis.

The means for recording the occurrence of the identified parameter(s) can advantageously be associated means for analysing the results of the information recorded so as to identify patterns, trends and anomalies within the telecommunications network and/or call-center.

Advantageously, the means for recording the occurrence of the identified parameter(s) can, in association with the means for identifying the predetermined parameter and the means for monitoring the telecommunications signals, be arranged to record the aforementioned occurrence in each of the two directions of traffic separately.

Preferably, the means for identifying the source of the two-way traffic includes means for receiving an identifier tagged on to the traffic so as to identify its source, i.e. the particular operative within the call-centre or the actual caller. Alternatively, means can be provided within the telecommunications monitoring apparatus for determining the terminal number, i.e. the telephone number, of the operative and/or the caller.

The aforementioned identification can also be achieved by way of data and/or speech recognition.

It should also be appreciated that the present invention can include means for providing an output indicative of the required identification of the at least one predetermined parameter. Such output can be arranged to drive audio and/or visual output means so that the call-centre provider can readily identify that a particular parameter has been identified and in which particular conversation the parameter has occurred. Alternatively, or in addition, the occurrence of the parameter can be recorded, on any appropriate medium for later analysis.

Of course, the mere single occurrence of a parameter need not establish an output from such output means and the apparatus can be arranged such that an output is only provided once a decision rule associated with such parameter(s) has been satisfied. Such a decision rule can be arranged such that it depends on present and/or past values of the parameter under consideration and/or other parameters.

Further, once a particular conversation has been identified as exhibiting a particular predetermined parameter, or satisfying a decision rule associated with such parameters, the apparatus can be arranged to allow ready access to the telecommunications “line” upon which the conversation is occurring so that the conversation can be interrupted or suspended as required.

As mentioned previously, the apparatus can be arranged to function in real time or, alternatively, the apparatus can include recording means arranged particularly to record the telecommunications traffic for later monitoring and analysis.

Preferably, the apparatus includes means for reconstructing the signals of the telecommunications traffic to their original form so as, for example, to replay the actual speech as it was delivered to the telecommunications network and/or call-center.

The apparatus can therefore advantageously recall the level of amplification, or attenuation, applied to the signal so as to allow for the subsequent analysis of the originating signal with its original amplitude envelope.

Further, the apparatus may include feedback means arranged to control the means for monitoring the telecommunications signals responsive to an output from means being provided to identify the source of the conversation in which the parameter has been identified, or the decision rule associated with the parameter has been exceeded.

A further embodiment of the present invention comprises an implementation in which means for recording and analysing the monitored signals are built into the actual system providing the transmission of the original signals so that the invention can advantageously take the form of an add-in card to an Automatic Call Distribution System or any other telecommunications system.

Also, it will be appreciated that the present invention can be advantageously arranged so as to be incorporated into a call-centre and indeed the present invention can provide for such a call-centre including apparatus as defined above.

In accordance with another aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of monitoring signals representing communications traffic, and comprising the steps of:

    • identifying at least one predetermined parameter associated with a monitored signal;
    • recording the occurrence of the identified parameter; and
    • identifying the traffic stream in which the parameter was identified.

The invention is therefore particularly advantageous in allowing the monitoring of respective parts of an at least two-way conversation and which may include the of analysis of the interaction of those parts.

Of course, the method of the present invention can advantageously be arranged to operate in accordance with the further apparatus features defined above.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The invention is described further hereinafter, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of a typical recording and analysis system embodying the present invention; and

FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating a typical data packetisation format employed within the present invention;

FIG. 3 is a flowchart of an example process for monitoring communications traffic and;

FIG. 4 is a list of exemplary parameters.

DESCRIPTION OF THE EMBODIMENT

As mentioned above, the apparatus can advantageously form part of a call-centre in which a plurality of telephone conversations can be monitored so as to provide the call-centre operator with information relating to the “quality” of the service provided by the call-centre operatives. Of course, the definition of “quality” will vary according to the requirements of the particular call-centre and, more importantly, the requirements of the customers to that call-centre but typical examples are bow well the call-centre operatives handle customers telephone calls, or how well an Interactive Voice Response System serves customers calling for, for example, product details.

The system generally comprises apparatus for the passive monitoring of voice or data signals, algorithms for the analysis of the monitored signals and, apparatus for the storage and reporting of the results of the analysis.

Optional features can include apparatus for recording the actual monitored signals particularly if real time operation is not required, and means for reconstructing the monitored signals into their original form so as to allow for, for example, replay of the speech signal.

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of a recording and analysis system for use in association with a call-centre 10 which includes an exchange switch 14 from which four telephone terminals 12 extend: each of which is used by one of four call-centre operatives handling customer enquiries/transactions via the exchange switch 14.

The monitoring apparatus 16 embodying the present invention, comprises a digital voice recorder 18 which is arranged to monitor the two-way conversation traffic associated with the exchange switch 14 by way of high impedance taps 20, 22 which are connected respectively to signal lines 24, 26 associated with the exchange switch 14 (Step 302; FIG. 3). As will be appreciated by the arrows employed for the signal lines 24, 26, the high impedance tap 20 is arranged to monitor outgoing voice signals from the call-centre 10 whereas the high impedance tap 22 is arranged to monitor incoming signals to the call-centre 10. The voice traffic on the lines 24, 26 therefore form a two-way conversation between a call-centre operative using one of the terminals 12 and a customer (not illustrated).

The monitoring apparatus 16 embodying the present invention further includes a computer telephone link 28 whereby data traffic appearing at the exchange switch 14 can be monitored as required.

The digital voice recorder 18 is connected to a network connection 30 which can be in the form of a wide area network (WAN), a local area network (LAN) or an internal bus of a central processing unit of a computer.

Also connected to the network connection 30 is a replay station 32, a configuration management application station 34, a station 36 providing speech and/or data analysis engine(s) and also storage means comprising a first storage means 38 for the relevant analysis rules and the results obtained and a second storage means 40 for storage of the data and/or speech monitor.

FIG. 2 illustrates the typical format of a data packet 42 used in accordance with the present invention and which comprises a packet header 44 of typically 48 bytes and a packet header 46 of typically of 2000 bytes.

The packet header is formatted so as to include the packet identification 48, the data format 50, a date and time stamp 52, the relevant channel number within which the data arises 54, the gain applied to the signal 56 and the data length 58.

The speech, or other data captured in accordance with the apparatus of the present invention, is found within the packet body 46 and within the format specified within the packet header 44.

The high impedance taps 20, 22 offer little or no effect on the transmission lines 24, 26 and, if not in digital form, the monitored signal is converted into digital form. For example, when the monitored signal comprises a speech signal, the signal is typically converted to a pulse code modulated (PCM) signal or is compressed as an Adaptive Differential PCM (ADPCM) signal.

Further, where signals are transmitted at a constant rate, the time of the start of the recordings is identified, for example by voltage or activity detection, i.e. so-called “vox” level detection, and the time is recorded. With asynchronous data signals, the start time of a data burst, and optionally the intervals between characters, may be recorded in addition to the data characters themselves.

The purpose of this is to allow a computer system to model the original signal to appropriate values of time, frequency and amplitude so as to allow the subsequent identification of one or more of the various parameters arising in association with the signal (see, FIG. 4). The digital information describing the original signals is then analysed at station 36, in real time or later, to determine the required set of metrics, i.e. parameters, appropriate to the particular application (Step 304; FIG. 3).

FIG. 3 is a flowchart of an example process 300 for monitoring communications traffic. At stage 302, signals representing communications traffic are monitored. For example, the digital voice recorder 18 can monitor two-way conversation traffic associated with the exchange switch 14. At stage 304, a predetermined parameter is identified by analyzing the content. For example, a digital signal processor programmed with an appropriate algorithm can identify the predetermined parameter. At stage 306, the occurrence of the identified parameter is recorded. For example, the first storage 38 (analysis rules and results) can store the occurrence of the identified parameter. At stage 308, the traffic stream associated with the parameter is identified. For example, the speech/data analysis engine 36 can identify the traffic stream. At stage 310, the recorded data relating to the occurrence is analyzed. For example, the speech/data analysis engine 36 can analyze the recorded data stored in the first storage 38.

FIG. 4 is a flowchart of an example process 400 that expands stage 304 in FIG. 3. At stage 402, a list of parameter types is determined, including: non-voice elements; the delay occurring, or the overlap between, transmissions in opposite directions; the amplitude envelope of the signals, so as to determine caller anger or episodes of shouting; the frequency spectrum of the signal in various frequency bands; ration of transmissions in each direction, the ratio of word to inter-word pauses; the language used by the speaker(s); the sex of the speaker(s); the presence or absence of particular words; the frequency and content of prosody; vibration or tremor within a voice; and the confidence/accuracy with which words are recognized to identify changes in speech patterns arising from a caller. This list may be defined in the call-centre 10 using the station 36 (speech and/or data analysis engine). At stage 404, parameters are selected from the parameter types. The selected parameters may be those that are considered appropriate to the requirements of the call-centre provider. At stage 406, an identification of one or more of the selected parameters is made. For example, the station 36 may identify parameters arising in association with the analysis of a signal being monitored.

A particular feature of the system is in recording the two directions of data transmission separately (Step 306; FIG. 3) so allowing further analysis of information sent in each direction independently (Steps 308-310; FIG. 3). In analogue telephone systems, this may be achieved by use of a four-wire (as opposed to two-wire) circuit whilst in digital systems, it is the norm to have the two directions of transmission separated onto separate wire pairs. In the data world, the source of each data packet is typically stored alongside the contents of the data packet.

A further feature of the system is in recording the level of amplification or attenuation applied to the original signal. This may vary during the monitoring of even a single interaction (e.g. through the use of Automatic Gain Control Circuitry). This allows the subsequent reconstruction and analysis of the original signal amplitude.

Another feature of the system is that monitored data may be “tagged” with additional information such as customer account numbers by an external system (e.g. the delivery of additional call information via a call logging port or computer telephony integration (CTI) port).

The importance of each of the parameters and the way in which they can be combined to highlight particularly good or bad interactions is defined by the user of the system (Step 310; FIG. 3). One or more such analysis profiles can be held in the system. These profiles determine the weighting given to each of the above parameters.

The profiles are normally used to rank a large number of monitored conversations and to identify trends, extremes, anomalies and norms. “Drill-down” techniques are used to permit the user to examine the individual call parameters that result in an aggregate or average score and, further, allow the user to select individual conversations to be replayed to confirm or reject the hypothesis presented by the automated analysis.

A particular variant that can be employed in any embodiment of the present invention uses feedback from the user's own scoring of the replayed calls to modify its own analysis algorithms. This may be achieved using neural network techniques or similar giving a system that learns from the user's own view of the quality of recordings.

A variant of the system uses its own and/or the scoring/ranking information to determine its further patterns of operation i.e.

    • determining which recorded calls to retain for future analysis,
    • determining which agents/lines to monitor and how often, and
    • determining which of the monitored signals to analyse and to what depth.

In many systems it is impractical to analyse all attributes of all calls hence a sampling algorithm may be defined to determine which calls will be analysed. Further, one or more of the parties can be identified (e.g. by calling-line identifier for the external party or by agent log-on identifiers for the internal party). This allows analysis of the call parameters over a number of calls handled by the same agent or coming from the same customer.

The system can use spare capacity on the digital signal processors (DSPs) that control the monitoring, compression or recording of the monitored signals to provide some or all of the analysis required. This allows analysis to proceed more rapidly during those periods when fewer calls are being monitored.

Spare CPU capacity on a PC at an agent's desk could be used to analyse the speech. This would comprise a secondary tap into the speech path being recorded as well as using “free” CPU cycles. Such an arrangement advantageously allows for the separation of the two parties, e.g. by tapping the headset/handset connection at the desk. This allows parameters relating to each party to be stored even if the main recording point can only see a mixed signal.

A further variant of the system is an implementation in which the systems recording and analysing the monitored signals are built into the system providing the transmission of the original signals (e.g. as an add-in card to an Automatic Call Distribution (ACD) system).

The apparatus illustrated is particularly useful for identifying the following parameters:

    • degree of interruption (i.e. overlap between agent talking and customer talking);
    • comments made during music or on-bold periods;
    • delays experienced by customers (i.e. the period from the end of their speech to an agent's response);
    • caller/agent talk ratios, i.e. which agents might be talking too much.

However, it should be appreciated that the invention could be adapted to identify parameters such as:

    • “relaxed/stressed” profile of a caller or agent (i.e. by determining changes in volume, speed and tone of speech)
    • frequency of keywords heard (separately from agents and from callers) e.g. are agents remembering to ask follow-up questions about a certain product/service etc; or how often do customers swear at each agent? Or how often do agents swear at customers?
    • frequency of repeat calls. A combination of line, ID and caller ID can be provided to eliminate different people calling from single switchboard/business number
    • languages used by callers?
    • abnormal speech patterns of agents. For example if the speech recognition applied to an agent is consistently and unusually inaccurate for, say, half an hour, the agent should be checked for: drug abuse, excessive tiredness, drunkenness, stress, rush to get away etc.

It will be appreciated that the illustrated and indeed any embodiments of the present invention can be set up as follows.

The Digital Trunk Lines (e.g. T1/E1) can be monitored trunk side and the recorded speech tagged with the direction of speech. A MediaStar Voice Recorder chassis can be provided typically with one or two E1/T1 cards plus a number of DSP cards for the more intense speech processing requirements.

Much of its work can be done overnight and in time, some could be done by the DSPs in the mediastar's own cards: It is also necessary to remove or at least recognise, periods of music, on-hold periods, IVR rather than real agents speaking etc. thus, bundling with Computer Integrated Telephony Services such as Telephony Services API (TSAPI) in many cases is appropriate.

Analysis and parameter identification as described above can then be conducted. However, as noted, if it is not possible to analyse all speech initially, analysis of a recorded signal can be conducted.

In any case the monitoring apparatus may be arranged to only search initially for a few keywords although re-play can be conducted so as to look for other keywords.

It should be appreciated that the invention is not restricted to the details of the foregoing embodiment. For example, any appropriate form of telecommunications network, or signal transmission media, can be monitored by apparatus according to this invention and the particular parameters identified can be selected, and varied, as required.

Patent Citations
Cited PatentFiling datePublication dateApplicantTitle
US38554181 Dec 197217 Dec 1974Fuller FMethod and apparatus for phonation analysis leading to valid truth/lie decisions by vibratto component assessment
US409382114 Jun 19776 Jun 1978John Decatur WilliamsonSpeech analyzer for analyzing pitch or frequency perturbations in individual speech pattern to determine the emotional state of the person
US414206711 Apr 197827 Feb 1979Williamson John DSpeech analyzer for analyzing frequency perturbations in a speech pattern to determine the emotional state of a person
US456751228 Sep 198328 Jan 1986World Video Library, Inc.Recorded program communication system
US483780413 Jan 19876 Jun 1989Mitsubishi Denki Kabushiki KaishaTelephone answering voiceprint discriminating and switching apparatus
US486670416 Mar 198812 Sep 1989California Institute Of TechnologyFiber optic voice/data network
US491270123 Dec 198727 Mar 1990Rockwell International CorporationPacket switching module
US49145866 Nov 19873 Apr 1990Xerox CorporationGarbage collector for hypermedia systems
US492448823 Feb 19898 May 1990Enforcement Support IncorporatedMultiline computerized telephone monitoring system
US493977120 Sep 19893 Jul 1990At&T Bell LaboratoriesAttendant-controlled call message delivery system and method
US49691368 Aug 19866 Nov 1990Chamberlin David BCommunications network and method with appointment information communication capabilities
US497246120 Sep 198920 Nov 1990At&T Bell LaboratoriesCall message delivery system and method
US49758968 Aug 19864 Dec 1990Agosto Iii Nicholas A DCommunications network and method
US50365396 Jul 198930 Jul 1991Itt CorporationReal-time speech processing development system
US50705268 Aug 19903 Dec 1991Active Voice, Inc.Signal analyzing system
US510140224 May 198831 Mar 1992Digital Equipment CorporationApparatus and method for realtime monitoring of network sessions in a local area network
US516697124 Feb 199224 Nov 1992Siemens AktiengesellschaftMethod for speaker recognition in a telephone switching system
US526094316 Jun 19929 Nov 1993Motorola, Inc.TDM hand-off technique using time differences
US52745726 Mar 199028 Dec 1993Schlumberger Technology CorporationMethod and apparatus for knowledge-based signal monitoring and analysis
US530950520 May 19913 May 1994Inventions, Inc.Automated voice system for improving agent efficiency and improving service to parties on hold
US533920321 Dec 199316 Aug 1994Dictaphone CorporationApparatus and method of retrieving a message from a digital audio tape
US53531685 Nov 19924 Oct 1994Racal Recorders LimitedRecording and reproducing system using time division multiplexing
US53554061 Mar 199311 Oct 1994Vmx, IncorporatedIntegrated application controlled call processing and messaging system
US5375068 *3 Jun 199220 Dec 1994Digital Equipment CorporationVideo teleconferencing for networked workstations
US5377051 *13 Jan 199327 Dec 1994Hitachi America, Ltd.Digital video recorder compatible receiver with trick play image enhancement
US53902431 Nov 199314 Feb 1995At&T Corp.Telemarketing complex with automatic threshold levels
US539637121 Dec 19937 Mar 1995Dictaphone CorporationEndless loop voice data storage and retrievable apparatus and method thereof
US53982454 Oct 199114 Mar 1995Bay Networks, Inc.Packet processing method and apparatus
US543479720 Oct 199418 Jul 1995Barris; Robert C.Audio communication system for a computer network
US5434913 *24 Nov 199318 Jul 1995Intel CorporationAudio subsystem for computer-based conferencing system
US544062410 Nov 19928 Aug 1995Netmedia, Inc.Method and apparatus for providing adaptive administration and control of an electronic conference
US544660321 Dec 199329 Aug 1995Dictaphone CorporationMethod of retrieving messages at selected times from a digital audio tape
US54484202 Aug 19935 Sep 1995Dictaphone CorporationMethod and a system for storing audio
US5475421 *16 Jul 199212 Dec 1995Digital Equipment CorporationVideo data scaling for video teleconferencing workstations communicating by digital data network
US5488570 *29 Jun 199430 Jan 1996Intel CorporationEncoding and decoding video signals using adaptive filter switching criteria
US548865214 Apr 199430 Jan 1996Northern Telecom LimitedMethod and apparatus for training speech recognition algorithms for directory assistance applications
US5490247 *24 Nov 19936 Feb 1996Intel CorporationVideo subsystem for computer-based conferencing system
US55007956 Jul 199419 Mar 1996Teknekron Infoswitch CorporationMethod and system for monitoring and controlling the performance of a call processing center
US5506954 *24 Nov 19939 Apr 1996Intel CorporationPC-based conferencing system
US5508942 *29 Jun 199416 Apr 1996Intel CorporationIntra/inter decision rules for encoding and decoding video signals
US5511003 *29 Jun 199423 Apr 1996Intel CorporationEncoding and decoding video signals using spatial filtering
US5515296 *29 Jun 19947 May 1996Intel CorporationScan path for encoding and decoding two-dimensional signals
US552640717 Mar 199411 Jun 1996Riverrun TechnologyMethod and apparatus for managing information
US55331037 Jun 19952 Jul 1996Electronic Information Systems, Inc.Calling system and method
US55352563 May 19959 Jul 1996Teknekron Infoswitch CorporationMethod and system for automatically monitoring the performance quality of call center service representatives
US553526120 Aug 19939 Jul 1996Gateway Technologies, Inc.Selectively activated integrated real-time recording of telephone conversations
US5546324 *22 Nov 199413 Aug 1996Digital Equipment CorporationVideo teleconferencing for networked workstations
US561529612 Nov 199325 Mar 1997International Business Machines CorporationContinuous speech recognition and voice response system and method to enable conversational dialogues with microprocessors
US562353927 Jan 199422 Apr 1997Lucent Technologies Inc.Using voice signal analysis to identify authorized users of a telephone system
US562369016 Jul 199222 Apr 1997Digital Equipment CorporationAudio/video storage and retrieval for multimedia workstations by interleaving audio and video data in data file
US564783430 Jun 199515 Jul 1997Ron; SamuelSpeech-based biofeedback method and system
US56573836 Jun 199512 Aug 1997Lucent Technologies Inc.Flexible customer controlled telecommunications handling
US569681120 Jun 19969 Dec 1997Teknekron Infoswitch CorporationMethod and system for automatically monitoring the performance quality of call center service representatives
US571295423 Aug 199527 Jan 1998Rockwell International Corp.System and method for monitoring audio power level of agent speech in a telephonic switch
US57178793 Nov 199510 Feb 1998Xerox CorporationSystem for the capture and replay of temporal data representing collaborative activities
US57197863 Feb 199317 Feb 1998Novell, Inc.Digital media data stream network management system
US573740525 Jul 19957 Apr 1998Rockwell International CorporationApparatus and method for detecting conversation interruptions in a telephonic switch
US576490121 Dec 19959 Jun 1998Intel CorporationRecord and playback in a data conference
US578725328 May 199628 Jul 1998The Ag GroupApparatus and method of analyzing internet activity
US579079831 May 19964 Aug 1998Witness Systems, Inc.Method and apparatus for simultaneously monitoring computer user screen and telephone activity from a remote location
US58025337 Aug 19961 Sep 1998Walker; Randall C.Text processor
US58189074 Aug 19976 Oct 1998Teknekron Infoswitch CorporationMethod and system for automatically monitoring the performance quality of call center service representatives
US581890927 Sep 19966 Oct 1998Van Berkum; Paul E.Agent speech detector system and method for use with a telephonic switch
US581900529 Mar 19966 Oct 1998Dictaphone CorporationModular digital recording logger
US582272721 Dec 199513 Oct 1998At&T CorpMethod for automatic speech recognition in telephony
US582618016 Aug 199420 Oct 1998Nice Systems Ltd.Near homodyne radio frequency receiver
US584838825 Mar 19948 Dec 1998British Telecommunications PlcSpeech recognition with sequence parsing, rejection and pause detection options
US58619596 Feb 199719 Jan 1999Nice Systems, Ltd.Facsimile long term storage and retrieval system
US591821322 Dec 199529 Jun 1999Mci Communications CorporationSystem and method for automated remote previewing and purchasing of music, video, software, and other multimedia products
US59370292 Aug 199610 Aug 1999Nice Systems, Ltd.Data logging system employing M N +1! redundancy
US594637512 May 199731 Aug 1999Teknekron Infoswitch CorporationMethod and system for monitoring call center service representatives
US596006314 Jul 199728 Sep 1999Kokusai Denshin Denwa Kabushiki KaishaTelephone speech recognition system
US598318620 Aug 19969 Nov 1999Seiko Epson CorporationVoice-activated interactive speech recognition device and method
US599952518 Nov 19967 Dec 1999Mci Communications CorporationMethod for video telephony over a hybrid network
US603501724 Jan 19977 Mar 2000Lucent Technologies Inc.Background speech recognition for voice messaging applications
US604682424 Jul 19974 Apr 2000Nice Systems, Ltd.Facsimile long term storage and retrieval system
US604706020 Feb 19984 Apr 2000Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc.Method and apparatus for enabling full interactive monitoring of calls to and from a call-in center
US605816312 May 19972 May 2000Teknekron Infoswitch CorporationMethod and system for monitoring call center service representatives
US610878224 Jun 199722 Aug 20003Com CorporationDistributed remote monitoring (dRMON) for networks
US612266526 Aug 199819 Sep 2000Sts Software System Ltd.Communication management system for computer network-based telephones
US61699048 Jul 19932 Jan 2001Qwest Communications International Inc.System and method for automatically distributing communications to selected locations
US62332343 Jun 199715 May 2001Bell Atlantic Network Services, Inc.Secure LAN/internet telephony
US623325612 Mar 199715 May 2001Sarnoff CorporationMethod and apparatus for analyzing and monitoring packet streams
US62467528 Jun 199912 Jun 2001Valerie BscheiderSystem and method for data recording
US624675926 Sep 199612 Jun 2001Rockwell International CorporationCall overflow system and method for overflowing telephone calls between telephonic switches
US62495708 Jun 199919 Jun 2001David A. GlownySystem and method for recording and storing telephone call information
US62529468 Jun 199926 Jun 2001David A. GlownySystem and method for integrating call record information
US62529478 Jun 199926 Jun 2001David A. DiamondSystem and method for data recording and playback
US628226910 Dec 199628 Aug 2001International Business Machines Corp.Voice mail on the internet
US62887395 Sep 199711 Sep 2001Intelect Systems CorporationDistributed video communications system
US632058818 Apr 199720 Nov 2001Compaq Computer CorporationAudio/video storage and retrieval for multimedia workstations
US633002510 May 199911 Dec 2001Nice Systems Ltd.Digital video logging system
US63517627 Jun 199626 Feb 2002Collaboration Properties, Inc.Method and system for log-in-based video and multimedia calls
US635629411 Aug 199812 Mar 20028×8, Inc.Multi-point communication arrangement and method
US637057416 Dec 19989 Apr 2002Witness Systems, Inc.Method and apparatus for simultaneously monitoring computer user screen and telephone activity from a remote location
US640485710 Feb 200011 Jun 2002Eyretel LimitedSignal monitoring apparatus for analyzing communications
US641821425 Sep 19979 Jul 2002British Telecommunications Public Limited CompanyNetwork-based conference system
US651022012 Mar 199821 Jan 2003Witness Systems, Inc.Method and apparatus for simultaneously monitoring computer user screen and telephone activity from a remote location
US653868428 Nov 199525 Mar 2003Canon Kabushiki KaishaTelevision conference system indicating time data
US654260214 Feb 20001 Apr 2003Nice Systems Ltd.Telephone call monitoring system
US65603231 Aug 19976 May 2003T-Netix, Inc.Computer-based method and apparatus for controlling, monitoring, recording and reporting telephone access
US65603283 Apr 19976 May 2003Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc.Voice extensions in a call-in center employing virtual restructuring for computer telephony integrated functionality
US65709677 Jun 199527 May 2003Ronald A. Katz Technology Licensing, L.P.Voice-data telephonic interface control system
US666804419 Jul 200023 Dec 2003Xtend Communications Corp.System and method for recording telephonic communications
US669066315 Jan 199810 Feb 2004Mci Communications CorporationInternet telephony system with automated call answering
US67283458 Jun 200127 Apr 2004Dictaphone CorporationSystem and method for recording and storing telephone call information
US675418118 Nov 199622 Jun 2004Mci Communications CorporationSystem and method for a directory service supporting a hybrid communication system architecture
US675736114 Feb 200229 Jun 2004Eyretel LimitedSignal monitoring apparatus analyzing voice communication content
US67753722 Jun 199910 Aug 2004Dictaphone CorporationSystem and method for multi-stage data logging
US67853698 Jun 200131 Aug 2004Dictaphone CorporationSystem and method for data recording and playback
Non-Patent Citations
Reference
1"Speech Analytics-The Art of Automated Voice Analysis in the Contact Center," Robert Frances Group IT Agenda, Feb. 26, 2002, 4 pgs.
2"Speech Analytics—The Art of Automated Voice Analysis in the Contact Center," Robert Frances Group IT Agenda, Feb. 26, 2002, 4 pgs.
3Abadjieva, Elissaveta et al., "Applying Analysis of Human Emotional Speech to Enhance Synthetic Speech," The MicroCentre, Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, The University, Scotland, U.K., 1993, pp. 909-912.
4Ades, Stephen, "An Architecture for Integrated Services on the Local Area Network," University of Cambridge, Computer Laboratory, Technical Report, No. 114, Sep. 1987, 177 pgs.
5AG Group, Inc., About Satellite, at http://web.archive.org/web/19980206033053/www.aggroup.com/skyline (Feb. 6, 1998), 1 p.
6Beckman, Mel, See and hear your network, at http://web.archive.org/web/1999022483147/macworld.zdnet.com/pages/june.96/Reviews.2144.html (Feb. 24, 1999), 3 pp.
7Boggs, David R. et al., Pup: An Internetwork Architecture, Report CSL-79-10, Xerox Palo Alto Research Center (Jul. 1979).
8Bullock, Darcy et al., "Roadway Traffic Control Software," IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, vol. 2, No. 3, Sep. 1994, pp. 255-264.
9Byun, Jae W. et al., "The Design and Analysis of an ATM Multicast Switch with Adaptive Traffic Controller," IEEE/ACM Transactions on Networking, vol. 2, No. 3, Jun. 1994, pp. 288-298.
10Cahn, Janet E., "The Generation of Affect in Synthesized Speech," Journal of the American Voice I/O Society, vol. 8 (Jul. 1990), pp. 1-19.
11Callegati, Franco et al., "On the Dimensioning of the Leaky Bucket Policing Mechanism for Multiplexer Congestion Avoidance," IEEE, 1993, pp. 617-621.
12Check Point, Check Point Fire Wall-1: Extensible Stateful Inspection, at http://web.archive.org/web/19980212235917/www.checkpoint.com/products/technology/page3.html (Feb. 12, 1998), 3 pp.
13Check Point, Stateful Inspection in Action, at http://web.archive.org/web/19980212235911/www.checkpoint.com/products/technology/page2.html (Feb. 12, 1998), 4 pp.
14Check Point, Supported Applications, at http://web.archive.org/web/19980212233542/www.checkpoint.com/products/technology/index.html (Feb. 12, 1998), 6 pp.
15Clark, David D. et al., Supporting Real-Time Applications in an Integrated Services Packet Network: Architecture and Mechanism, Conference Proceedings on Communications Architectures & Protocols (Aug. 17-20, 1992).
16Clark, main loop for Internet protocol (WSISTS066835-WSISTS066838), Dec. 3, 1979.
17Cohen, D. "A Voice Message System", Proceedings of the IFIP TC-6 International Symposium on Computer Message Systems, Computer Message Systems, edited by Ronald P. Uhlig, Bell Northern Research Limited, Ottawa, Canada, Apr. 6-8, 1981, pp. 17-28.
18Cohen, D. "On Packet Speech Communication", Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference, Computer Communications: Increasing Benefits to Society, The International Council for Computer Communication, Hosted by American Telephone and Telegraph Company., Atlanta, Georgia, Oct. 27-30, 1980. pp. 269-274.
19Cohen, Danny "Using Local Area Networks for Carrying Online Voice," Proceedings of the IFIP TC 6 International In-Depth Symposium on Local Computer Networks, edited by Piercarlo Ravasio, Ing. Olivetti & C.S.p. A., Ivrea, Italy, Greg Hopkins, The MITRE Corporation, Medford, Massachusetts, and Najah Naffah, INRIA, Le Chesnay, France, North Holland Publishing Company, Florence, Italy, Apr. 19-21, 1982, pp. 13-21.
20Cohen, Danny et al., "A Network Voice Protocol NVP-II," USC/ISI, ISI/RR-81-90, Apr. 1, 1981, 75 pgs.
21Cohen, Danny, "Packet communication of online speech", USCI, Information Sciences Institute, Marina del Rey, CA, National Computer Conference, 1981, pp. 169-176.
22Cohen, Danny, NWG/RFC 741, "Specification for the Network Voice Protocol (NVP)", ISI, DC, Nov. 22, 1977, 40 pages.
23Cohen, Danny, USC/ISI, Summary of the ARPA/Ethernet Community Meeting, Xerox-PARC, Nov. 1979, 16 pgs.
24Communications Solutions CTI News, at http://www.tmcnet.com/articles/ctimag/0699/0699news.htm, Jun. 1999.
25CTI News, Year End Issue, New Products From Amtelco XDS, Technology Marketing Corporation, 2007, 18 pgs.
26Emmerson, Bob et al., "The Surging CTI Tide," Byte, Nov. 1996, 3 pgs.
27Engineering and Operations in the Bell System (Second edition), Members of the Technical Staff and the Technical Publication Department, AT&T Bell Laboratories, Murray Hill, New Jersey, 1984, 6 pages.
28Erimli, Bahadir et al., "On Worst Case Traffic in ATM Networks," The Institution of Electrical Engineers, IEE, Savoy Place, London, U.K., 1995, 12 pages.
29Frick, Robert W., "Communicating Emotion: The Role of Prosodic Features," Psychological Bulletin, vol. 97, No. 3, 1985, pp. 412-429.
30Glover, Mark V., "Internetworking: Distance Learning 'To Sea' via Disktop Videoconferencing Tools and IP Multicast Protocols" (Mar. 1998) (unpublished M. Sc. Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California).
31Glover, Mark V., "Internetworking: Distance Learning ‘To Sea’ via Disktop Videoconferencing Tools and IP Multicast Protocols" (Mar. 1998) (unpublished M. Sc. Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California).
32Hamel, Gary et al., "Strategic Intent," Harvard Business Review (HBR), (May-Jun. 1989), 14 pgs.
33Hargadon, Andrew et al., "Building an Innovation Factory," Harvard Business Review (HBR OnPoint), Product No. 6102 (May-Jun. 2000), pp. 1, 3-17.
34Herrell, Elizabeth, "Genesys And VoiceGenie: Speech Leaders Merge," QuickTake, Forrester Research, Apr. 11, 2006, 2 pgs.
35Herrell, Elizabeth, "Telephony @Work Globalizes Contact Center Platform with Multi-Lingual Support," IdeaByte, copyright 2002 Giga Information Group, Mar. 11, 2002, 1 pg.
36Hirschberg, Julia et al., "Experiments in Emotional Speech," Columbia University (Feb. 18, 2003), 4 pgs.
37Hirschberg, Julia et al., "Prosodic and Other Cues to Speech Recognition Failures," Department of Elsevier B.V., Speech Communication, vol. 43 (2004) pp. 155-175.
38Hirschberg, Julia et al., "The influence of pitch range, duration, amplitude and spectral features on the interpretation of the rise-fall-rise intonation contour in English," Journal of Phonetics, vol. 20, (1992) pp. 241-251.
39Holfelder, W., "Interactive Remote Recording and Playback of Multicase Videoconferences," in Interactive Distributed Multimedia Systems and Telecommunications Services, 4th International Workshop, IDMS '97, Darmstadt, Germany, 450-463 (Sep. 10-12, 1997 Proceedings, Steinmetz, R. and Wolf, L. Eds).
40Holfelder, Wieland, Tenet Group, International Computer Science Institute and University of California, "VCR(1), MBone VCR-Mbone Video Conference Recorder", Berkley, CA, Nov. 5, 1995, pp. 1-8.
41Holfelder, Wieland, Tenet Group, International Computer Science Institute and University of California, "VCR(1), MBone VCR—Mbone Video Conference Recorder", Berkley, CA, Nov. 5, 1995, pp. 1-8.
42Howell, Peter et al., "Development of a Two-Stage Procedure for the Automatic Recognition of Dysfluencies in the Speech of Children Who Stutter: I. Psychometric Procedures Appropriate for Selection of Training Material for Lexical Dysfluency Classifiers," University College London, Department of Psychology, J Speech Lang Hear Res., vol. 40, Issue 5, pp. 1073-1084 (Oct. 1997).
43Howell, Peter et al., "Development of a Two-Stage Procedure for the Automatic Recognition of Dysfluencies in the Speech of Children Who Stutter: II. ANN Recognition of Repetitions and Prolongations With Supplied Word Segment Markers," University College London England, UKPMC Funders Group, J Speech Lang Hear Res., vol. 40, Issue 5 (Oct. 1997), pp. 1085-1096.
44Information Sciences Institute, University of Southern California, Marina del Rey, "RFC:791 Internet Protocal DARPA Internet Program Protocol Specification", Prepared for Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency Information Processing Techniques Office, Arlington, VA, Sep. 1981, pp. 1-45.
45Intel Corporation, Intel Internet Video Phone Trial Applet 2.1: The Problems and Pitfalls of Getting H.323 Safely Through Firewalls, at web.archive.org/web/19980425132417//http://support.intel.com/support/videophone/trial21/h323-wpr.htm#a18 (Apr. 24, 1998), 32 pp.
46Intel Corporation, Intel Internet Video Phone Trial Applet 2.1: The Problems and Pitfalls of Getting H.323 Safely Through Firewalls, at web.archive.org/web/19980425132417//http://support.intel.com/support/videophone/trial21/h323—wpr.htm#a18 (Apr. 24, 1998), 32 pp.
47Lazarus, David, "Now call centers can make Nice on Phone," SFGate.com, Jan. 30, 2005, 4 pgs.
48Lieberman et al., "Some Aspects of Fundamental Frequency and Envelope Amplitude as Related to the Emotional Content of Speech", The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 34, previously presented. 922-927 (Jul. 1962).
49Magar, Surendar S. et al., "A Microcomputer with Digital Signal Processing Capability," Session II: Digital Signal Processors, ISSCC 82, IEEE, 1982, 4 pages.
50Mash Research Team, Archive Tools Overview (last modified Aug. 30, 1997) at http://web.archive.org/web/19980209092409/mash.cs.berkeley.edu/mash/software/archive-usage.html (archived Feb. 9, 1998).
51Mash Research Team, Player, at web.archive.org/web/19980209092521/mash.cs.berkeley.edu/mash (Feb. 9, 1998), 3 pp.
52Mash Research Team, Recorder, at http://web.archive.org/web/19980209092445/mash.cs.berkeley.edu/mash/software/recorder-usage.html (archived Feb. 9, 1998).
53Mash Research Team, vic-video conference, at web.archive.org/web/19980209092254/mash.cs.berkeley.edu/mash (Feb. 9, 1998), 11 pp.
54Maxemchuk, N.F., "An Experimental Speech Storage and Editing Facility," American Telephone and Telegraph Company, The Bell System Technical Journal, vol. 59, No. 8 (Oct. 1980), pp. 1383-1395.
55McCanne, et al., "The BSD Packet Filter: A New Architecture for User-level Packet Capture," Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, Berkeley, California, (preprint of paper to be presented at the 1993 Winter USENIX conference, Jan. 25-29, 1993, San Diego, California), (Dec. 19, 1992), 11 pgs.
56Microsoft Corporation, GFF Format Summary: Microsoft RIFF, at http://netghost.narod.ru/gff/graphics/summary/micriff.htm (1996), 5 pp.
57Nance, Barry, "Your PC's Ringing-Answer It!," CMP Media LLC, Byte Digest, Byte.com, (archived Feb. 1997), 5 pgs.
58Nance, Barry, "Your PC's Ringing—Answer It!," CMP Media LLC, Byte Digest, Byte.com, (archived Feb. 1997), 5 pgs.
59Network Resource Group of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, vat-LBNL Audio Conferencing Took, at web.archive.org/web/19980126183021/www-nrg.ee.lbl.gov/vat (Jan. 26, 1998), 5 pp.
60Neustein, Amy, "Sequence Package Analysis: A Data Mining Tool to Speed Up Wiretap Analysis," Linguistic Technology Systems, Edgewater, New Jersey, presented at AVIOS May 10, 2002, 4 pgs.
61Neustein, Amy, "Using Sequence Package Analysis to Improve Natural Language Understanding," Linguistic Technology Systems, New York, New York, Kluwer Academic Publishers, International Journal of Speech Technology vol. 4 (2001), pp. 31-44.
62Neustein, Ph.D., Amy, "Sequence Package Analysis: A New Natural Language Understanding Method for Performing Data Mining of Help-Line Calls and Doctor-Patient Interviews," Linguistic Technology Systems, Edgewater, New Jersey, published proceedings of the Natural Language Understanding and Cognitive Science Workshop at the 6th ICEIS (University of Portugal, Apr. 13, 2004), 11 pgs.
63Nice Systems Ltd.'s content analysis package, "Emotion Detection," Ra'Anana, Israel, 2005, 33 pages.
64Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems, Ltd.'s Local Patent Rule (LPR) 4.3 Disclosures (including claim chart) submitted to the Court in Witness Systems, Inc. v. Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems, Ltd., District Court Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:06-CV-11026-RLV on May 1, 2006, 236 pgs.
65Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems, Ltd.'s Second Supplemental Local Patent Rule 4.3 Disclosures submitted to the Court in Witness Systems, Inc. v. Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems, Ltd., District Court Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:06-CV-00126-TCB on Oct. 23, 2007, 6 pgs.
66Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems, Ltd.'s Supplemental Local Patent Rule 4.3 Disclosures (including claim chart) submitted to the Court in Witness Systems, Inc. v. Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems, Ltd., District Court Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:06-CV-00126-TCB on Sep. 28, 2007, 131 pgs.
67Nicholson, Robert T., "Integrating Voice in the Office World," Byte Publications Inc., McGraw-Hill, vol. 8, No. 12 (Dec. 1983), pp. 177-184.
68Ober, Katie, "Assessing Validity of Computerized Voice Stress Analysis," study conducted at Edinboro University of Pennsylvania, presented at the 31st Annual Western Pennsylvania Undergraduate Psychology Conference-Mercyhurst College, Erie, Pennsylvania, Apr. 2003, 2 pgs.
69Ober, Katie, "Assessing Validity of Computerized Voice Stress Analysis," study conducted at Edinboro University of Pennsylvania, presented at the 31st Annual Western Pennsylvania Undergraduate Psychology Conference—Mercyhurst College, Erie, Pennsylvania, Apr. 2003, 2 pgs.
70O'Mahony, Dr. Donal, Networks & Telecommunications Research Group, Trinity College Dublin, 1998, 80 pgs.
71Oppenheim, Alan V. et al., "Digital Signal Processing," Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1974, 4 pages.
72Parnes, Peter et al., mMOD: The Multicast Media-on-Demand System, Lulea University of Technology, Sweden, Mar. 6, 1997.
73Postel, Jonathan B. et al., The ARPA Internet Protocol, Computer Networks: The International Journal of Distributed Informatique, vol. 5, No. 4 (Jul. 1981).
74Posting of Brett Eldridge to muc.lists.firewalls: MS NetMeeting 2.0 and Raptor Eagle vers. 4.0, at roups-beta.google.com/groups/muc.lists.firewalls/browse-thread/thread/ec0255b64bf36ad4?tvc=2 (May 2, 1997), 3 pp.
75Posting of Brett Eldridge to muc.lists.firewalls: MS NetMeeting 2.0 and Raptor Eagle vers. 4.0, at roups-beta.google.com/groups/muc.lists.firewalls/browse—thread/thread/ec0255b64bf36ad4?tvc=2 (May 2, 1997), 3 pp.
76Posting of Dameon D. Welch-Abernathy, Re: [fw1-wizards] tcpdump for solaris 2.6, at http://oldfaq.phoneboy.com/gurus/200007/msg00081.html, Jul. 18, 2000.
77Posting of Michael Pelletier to comp. security.firewalls: Netmeeting through a packet filter, at http://groups-beta.google.com/group/comp.security.firewalls/browse-thread/thread/c14c3ac7d190a58/a4010ede22ff83a0, Jan. 23, 1998, 4 pgs.
78Posting of Michael Pelletier to comp. security.firewalls: Netmeeting through a packet filter, at http://groups-beta.google.com/group/comp.security.firewalls/browse—thread/thread/c14c3ac7d190a58/a4010ede22ff83a0, Jan. 23, 1998, 4 pgs.
79Press Release, PhoNet Communications Ltd., "PhoNet Communications Introduces PhoNetWork For Voice Calls over Intranets or the Internet," Oct. 10, 1997, 1 pg.
80Press Release, PhoNet Communications Ltd., "PhoNet Introduces EtherPhone: The First Data PBX Solution to Offer Toll Quality, Scalability, and Fault Tolerance Regardless of Network Topology," Oct. 10, 1997, 2 pgs.
81Press Release, RADCOM, Breakthrough Internetworking Application for Latency & Loss Measurements from RADCOM, at web.archive.org/web/19980527022443/www.radcom-inc.com/press21.htm (May 27, 1998), 2 pp.
82Press Release, RADCOM, New VoIP Testing Applications from RADCOM, at www.radcom.com/radcom/about/pr020999.htm, Feb. 9, 1999, 2 pgs.
83Press Release, RADCOM, RADCOM Adds UNI 4.0 Signalling and MPEG-II Support to ATM Analysis Solutions, at http://web.archive.org/web/19980527022611/www.radcom-inc.com/press13.htm (May 27, 1998) 1 p.
84Rabiner, Lawrence R., "A Tutorial on Hidden Markov Models and Selected Applications in Speech Recognition," Proceedings of the IEEE, vol. 77, No. 2 (Feb. 1989), pp. 257-286.
85RADCOM, Prism200 Multiport WAN/LAN/ATM Analyzer, at hweb.archive.org/web/19980527020144/www.radcom-inc.com/pro-p1.htm (May 27, 1998), 3 pp.
86RADCOM, PrismLite: Portable WAN/LAN/ATM Protocol Analyzer, at http://web.archive.org/web/19980527020156/www.radcom-inc.com/pro-p2.htm (May 27, 1998), 3 pp.
87RADCOM, Supported Protocols, at web.archive.org/web/19980527014033/www.radcom-inc.com/protocol.htm (May 27, 1998), 10 pp.
88Raman et al., "On-demand Remote Playback", Paper, Department of EECS, University of California at Berkeley (1997), 10 pp.
89Rose, Richard C., "Discriminant Wordspotting Techniques for Rejecting Non-Vocabulary Utterances in Unconstrained Speech," IEEE, 1992, pp. 105-108.
90Ruiz, Antonio, Voice and Telephony Applications for the Office Workstation, 1st International Conference on Computer Workstations, IEEE Computer Society Press (Nov. 11-14, 1985).
91Russ, Donna, "Speech Recognition: Ripe for the Picking," Customer Interface (Jun. 2002), 3 pgs.
92Saltzer, Jerome H. et al., "The Desktop Computer as a Network Participant," IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, vol. SAC-3, No. 3 (May 1985), pp. 468-478.
93Schmandt, Chris et al., "An Audio and Telephone Server for Multi-Media Workstations," Media Laboratory, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, IEEE, 1988, pp. 150-159.
94Schooler, Eve M. et al., "A Packet-switched Multimedia Conferencing System," University of Southern California, Information Sciences Institute, Marina del Rey, California, Reprinted from the ACM SIGOIS Bulletin, vol. 1, No. 1 (Jan. 1989), pp. 12-22.
95Schuett, A. et al., A Soft State Protocol for Accessing Multimedia Archives, Proc. 8th International Workshop on Network and Operating Systems Support for Digital Audio and Video (NOSSDSV), Jul. 1998, 11 pgs.
96Schulzrinne, Henning, "NeVoTImplementation and Program Structure", GMD Fokus, Berlin, Feb. 9, 1996, pp. 1-16.
97Schulzrinne, Henning, "Voice Communication Across the Internet: A Network Voice Terminal", Dept. of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Dept. of Computer Science, Univ. of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA Jul. 29, 1992, pp. 1-34.
98Simpson, David, Viewing RTPDump Files, at http://bmrc.berkeley.edu/~davesimp/viewingNotes.html (Oct. 12, 1996), 1 p.
99Simpson, David, Viewing RTPDump Files, at http://bmrc.berkeley.edu/˜davesimp/viewingNotes.html (Oct. 12, 1996), 1 p.
100So-Lin Yen et al. "Intelligent MTS Monitoring System", Oct. 1994, pp. 185-187, Scientific and Research Center for Criminal Investigation, Taiwan, Republic of China.
101So-Lin Yen et al., "Intelligent MTS Monitoring System", Oct. 1994, pp. 185-187, Scientific and Research Center for Criminal Investigation, Taiwan, Republic of China.
102Southcott, C.B. et al., "Voice Control of the Pan-European Digital Mobile Radio System," IEEE, 1989, pp. 1070-1074.
103Speech Processing Peripheral (SPP) User's Manual, Adams-Russell Company, Inc., Digital Processing Division, Waltham, Massachusetts, Oct. 2, 1984, 64 pgs.
104Swinehart, D.C. et al., Adding Voice to an Office Computer Network, IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference, San Diego, California, Conference Record vol. 1 of 3 (Nov. 28-Dec. 1, 1983.
105Swinehart, Daniel C., Telephone Management in the Etherphone System, IEEE/IEICE Global Telecommunications Conference, Tokyo Conference Proceedings, vol. 2 of 3 (1987).
106Telecommunication Standardization Sector of International Telecommunication Union, Recommendation H.225 Call Signaling Protocols and Media Stream Packetization for Packet-Based Multimedia Communication Systems, Feb. 1998 (WSISTS000177-331).
107Telecommunication Standardization Sector of International Telecommunication Union, Recommendation H.245 Control Protocol for Multimedia Communication, Feb. 1998.
108Telecommunication Standardization Sector of International Telecommunication Union, Recommendation H.323 Packet-Based Multimedia Communications Systems, Feb. 1998 (WSISTS000049-176).
109Terry, Douglas B. and Daniel C. Swinehart, "Managing Stored Voice in the Etherphone System", Computer Science Laboratory, Xerox Palo Alto Research Center, 1987, pp. 103-104.
110Terry, Douglas B. et al., Managing Stored Voice in the Etherphone System, ACM Transactions on Computer Systems, vol. 6, No. 1, ACM 0734-2071/88/0200-0003 (Feb. 1988).
111Terry, Douglas B., Distributed System Support for Voice in Cedar, Proc. Of Second European SIGOPS Workshop on Distributed Systems (Aug. 1986).
112The AG Group, Inc., User Manual: Etherpeek Ethernet Network Software Analysis (1997), 168 pp.
113Thomas, Robert H. et al., "Diamond: A Multimedia Message System Built on a Distributed Architecture," IEEE, (Dec. 1985), pp. 65-78.
114Thomke, Stefan, "Enlightened Experimentation: The New Imperative for Innovation," Harvard Business Review (HBR OnPoint), Product No. 6099 (Feb. 2001), pp. 1, 31-47.
115Touchstone Technologies, Inc., "Voice and Video over IP Test Solutions," Hatboro, Pennsylvania, (Sep. 19, 2006), 3 pgs.
116Vin, Harrick M. et al., Multimedia Conferencing in the Etherphone Environment, IEEE Computer Society Press, vol. 24, Issue 10 (Oct. 1991).
117Von Hippel, Eric et al., "Creating Breakthroughs at 3M," Harvard Business Review (HBR OnPoint), Product No. 6110 (Sep.-Oct. 1999), pp. 1, 19-29, 47.
118Waldbusser, S., RFC 1757-Remote Network Monitoring Management Information Base, at http://www.faqs.org/rfcs/rfc1747.htm1 (Feb. 1995), 65 pp.
119Waldbusser, S., RFC 1757—Remote Network Monitoring Management Information Base, at http://www.faqs.org/rfcs/rfc1747.htm1 (Feb. 1995), 65 pp.
120Wessler, Dr. Barry, Rebuttal Expert Report, submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 6, 2007, 38 pages.
121Willis, David, "Hear it for yourself: Audio Samples from our H.323 test, Network Computing," at http://www.nwc.com/1001/1001ws2.html, Jan. 11, 1999.
122Willis, David, "Voice Over IP, The Way It Should Be," Network Computing, at http://www.nwc.com/1001/1001ws12.html, Jan. 11, 1999.
123Wilpon, Jay G. et al., "Automatic Recognition of Keywords in Unconstrained Speech Using Hidden Markov Models," IEEE Transactions on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, vol. 38, No. 11, Nov. 1990, pp. 1870-1878.
124Witness Systems, Inc. Rebuttal Expert Report of Stephen Casner (75 pgs) with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E—17 pgs; Exhibit F—21 pgs; Exhibit H—38 pgs; and Exhibit L—26 pgs), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
125Witness Systems, Inc., claim chart exhibits from Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark on Invalidity (Exhibit L-43 pgs.; Exhibit M-19 pgs. Exhibit N-94 pgs.; and Exhibit O-61 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
126Witness Systems, Inc., claim chart exhibits from Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark on Invalidity (Exhibit L—43 pgs.; Exhibit M—19 pgs. Exhibit N—94 pgs.; and Exhibit O—61 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
127Witness Systems, Inc., claim chart exhibits from Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark on Invalidity (Exhibit P-13 pgs.; Exhibit Q-13 pgs. Exhibit R-22 pgs.; Exhibit S-50 pgs.; Exhibit T-24 pgs.; Exhibit U-66 pgs.; Exhibit V-41 pgs.; and Exhibit W-36 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
128Witness Systems, Inc., claim chart exhibits from Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark on Invalidity (Exhibit P—13 pgs.; Exhibit Q—13 pgs. Exhibit R—22 pgs.; Exhibit S—50 pgs.; Exhibit T—24 pgs.; Exhibit U—66 pgs.; Exhibit V—41 pgs.; and Exhibit W—36 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
129Witness Systems, Inc., claim chart exhibits from Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark (Exhibit P-12 pgs.; Exhibit Q-12 pgs.; Exhibit R-19 pgs.; Exhibit S-47 pgs.; Exhibit U-63 pgs.; Exhibit V-37 pgs.; and Exhibit W-32 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
130Witness Systems, Inc., claim chart exhibits from Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark (Exhibit P—12 pgs.; Exhibit Q—12 pgs.; Exhibit R—19 pgs.; Exhibit S—47 pgs.; Exhibit U—63 pgs.; Exhibit V—37 pgs.; and Exhibit W—32 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
131Witness Systems, Inc., Expert Report of Danny Cohen on Invalidity (28 pgs) with claim cart Exhibit C (44 pgs), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Sep. 19, 2007.
132Witness Systems, Inc., Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark on Invalidity (60 pgs), with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E—38 pgs; Exhibit F—23 pgs; Exhibit G—37 pgs; Exhibit H—32 pgs; Exhibit I—62 pgs; Exhibit J—39 pgs; Exhibit K—41 pgs; Exhibit L—43 pgs; Exhibit M—19 pgs; Exhibit N—94 pgs; Exhibit O—61 pgs; Exhibit P—13 pgs; Exhibit Q—13 pgs; Exhibit R—22 pgs; Exhibit S—50 pgs; Exhibit T—24 pgs; Exhibit U—66 pgs; Exhibit V—41 pgs; and Exhibit W—36 pgs), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern.
133Witness Systems, Inc., Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark on Invalidity (60 pgs.), with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E-38 pgs.; Exhibit F-23 pgs.; Exhibit G-37 pgs.; Exhibit H-32 pgs.; Exhibit I-62 pgs.; Exhibit J-39 pgs.; and Exhibit K-41 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
134Witness Systems, Inc., Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark on Invalidity (60 pgs.), with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E—38 pgs.; Exhibit F—23 pgs.; Exhibit G—37 pgs.; Exhibit H—32 pgs.; Exhibit I—62 pgs.; Exhibit J—39 pgs.; and Exhibit K—41 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
135Witness Systems, Inc., Expert Report of Dr. Jeffrey S. Vitter on Validity (including claim chart), submitted to the Court in Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, for the District of Delaware, Case No. 06-311-JJF on Dec. 21, 2007 (85 pgs).
136Witness Systems, Inc., Expert Report of John Henits on Validity Issues, submitted to the Court in Nice Systems, Inc. and Nice Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, for the District of Delaware, Case No. 06-311-JJF on Dec. 31, 2007 (99 pgs).
137Witness Systems, Inc., Expert Report of Stephen L. Casner on Invalidity (39 pgs), with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E—20 pgs; Exhibit F—24 pgs; Exhibit G—20 pgs; Exhibit H—41 pgs; Exhibit I—19 pgs; Exhibit J—20 pgs; Exhibit K—29 pgs; and Exhibit L—30 pgs), submitted to the Court in Sts Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Sep. 21, 2007.
138Witness Systems, Inc., Fourth Supplemental Local Patent Rule (LPR) 4.3 Disclosures (including claim chart), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Mar. 22, 2007, 69 pages.
139Witness Systems, Inc., Local Patent Rule (LPR) 4.3 Disclosures (including claim chart), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Apr. 25, 2005, 36 pgs.
140Witness Systems, Inc., Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. Danny Cohen (53 pages) with claim chart Exhibit C (44 pgs), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
141Witness Systems, Inc., Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. David Clark (111 pgs), with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E—35 pgs; Exhibit J—36 pgs; Exhibit O—58 pgs; Exhibit P—12 pgs; Exhibit Q—12 pgs; Exhibit R—19 pgs; Exhibit S—47 pgs; Exhibit U—63 pgs; Exhibit V—37 pgs; and Exhibit W—32 pgs), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
142Witness Systems, Inc., Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark (115 pgs.), with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E-35 pgs.; Exhibit J-36 pgs.; and Exhibit O-58 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
143Witness Systems, Inc., Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. David D. Clark (115 pgs.), with claim chart exhibits (Exhibit E—35 pgs.; Exhibit J—36 pgs.; and Exhibit O—58 pgs.), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Nov. 20, 2007.
144Witness Systems, Inc., Second Supplemental Local Patent Rule (LPR) 4.3 Disclosures (including claim chart), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Jan. 29, 2007, 48 pgs.
145Witness Systems, Inc., Supplemental Local Patent Rule (LPR) 4.3 Disclosures (including claim chart), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Sep. 9, 2005, 19 pgs.
146Witness Systems, Inc., Third Supplemental Local Patent Rule (LPR) 4.3 Disclosures (including claim chart), submitted to the Court in STS Software Systems Ltd. v. Witness Systems, Inc. et al., U.S. District Court Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, Case No. 1:04-CV-2111-RWS on Feb. 20, 2007, 20 pgs.
147Zellweger, Polle T., Douglas B. Terry, and Daniel C. Swinehart, "An Overview of the Etherphone System and Its Applications", Xerox Palo Alto Research Center, Palo Alto, CA, 1988, pp. 160-168.
Referenced by
Citing PatentFiling datePublication dateApplicantTitle
US20090034436 *12 May 20085 Feb 2009Verint Americas Inc.Systems and methods of recording solution interface
Classifications
U.S. Classification379/67.1, 709/204, 348/14.1, 345/501, 704/275, 379/202.01
International ClassificationH04M7/12, H04M3/36, H04M3/42, H04M3/22, H04M1/64, H04M3/51, G10L17/00, G10L17/26
Cooperative ClassificationG10L17/26, G10L17/005, H04M3/42323, H04M3/2272, H04M3/42221, H04M2201/40, H04M3/5175, G10L15/265
European ClassificationG10L15/26A, H04M3/51S, G10L17/00U, G10L17/26
Legal Events
DateCodeEventDescription
21 Oct 2013ASAssignment
Effective date: 20130918
Free format text: GRANT OF SECURITY INTEREST IN PATENT RIGHTS;ASSIGNOR:VERINT AMERICAS INC.;REEL/FRAME:031465/0450
Owner name: CREDIT SUISSE AG, CAYMAN ISLANDS BRANCH, AS COLLAT
1 Oct 2013IPRAia trial proceeding filed before the patent and appeal board: inter partes review
Free format text: TRIAL NO: IPR2013-00492
Opponent name: CALLCOPY, INC.
Effective date: 20130802
29 Mar 2013ASAssignment
Free format text: CHANGE OF NAME;ASSIGNOR:WITNESS SYSTEMS, INC.;REEL/FRAME:030112/0585
Owner name: VERINT AMERICAS INC., GEORGIA
Effective date: 20070525
5 Feb 2007ASAssignment
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:BLAIR, CHRISTOPHER DOUGLAS;KEENAN, ROGER LOUIS;SIGNING DATES FROM 19970915 TO 19970916;REEL/FRAME:018850/0067
Owner name: EYRETEL LIMITED, UNITED KINGDOM
Effective date: 20060117
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNOR:EYRETEL LIMITED, DBA WITNESS SYSTEMS LTD.;REEL/FRAME:018850/0108
Owner name: WITNESS SYSTEMS, INC., GEORGIA