US3907834A - Process for producing maleic anhydride - Google Patents

Abstract

The process in this invention relates to the conversion of organic compounds selected from the group consisting of the nbutylenes, butadiene, crotonaldehyde and furan in a selective manner to maleic anhydride in the presence of a catalyst comprising the mixed oxides of antimony and molybdenum.

Description

United States Patent [191 Milberger et al.

[ Sept. 23, 1975 PROCESS FOR PRODUCING MALEIC ANHYDRIDE [75] lnventors: Ernest C. Milberger, Solon; Serge R. Dolhyj, Parma; Harley F. l-Iardman, Lyndhurst, all of Ohio [73] Assignee: The Standard Oil Company,

Cleveland, Ohio [22] Filed: Sept. 1, 1971 [2 1] Appl. No.: 177,105

FOREIGN PATENTS OR APPLICATIONS 1,155,176 6/1969 United Kingdom 260/3468 X United Kingdom Japan Primary Examiner-Henry R, Jiles Assistant Examiner.-Bernard Dentz Attorney, Agent, or FirmHerbert D. Knudsen [57] ABSTRACT The process in this invention relates to the conversion of organic compounds selected from the-group consisting of the n-butylenes, butadiene, crotonaldehyde and furan in a selective manner to maleic anhydride in the presence of a catalyst comprising the mixed oxides of antimony and molybdenum.

7 Claims, No Drawings I about 20 to 30. The preferred catalysts include those PROCESS FOR PRODUCING MALEIC ANHYDRIDE This invention relates to a process for the manufacture of maleic anhydride by the catalytic oxidation of unsaturated organic compounds containing at least four carbon atoms. More particularly this invention relates to the conversion of organic compounds selected from the group consisting of the n-butylenes, butadicue-1,3, crotonaldehyde and furan to maleic anhydride in the presence of a catalyst comprising the mixed oxides of antimony and molybdenum. Also within the scope of this invention is the method for preparing the catalyst employed in this process.

The catalyst of this invention is composed of the oxides of molybdenum and antimony and optionally may contain other metal oxides. The catalyst compositions most useful in this invention are represented by the following formula:

n b c d wherein A is a member selected from the group consisting of molybdenum, tungsten, magnesium, aluminum and nickel, and wherein a is a number of from to 0.2, b is a number of from 1 to 9, c is a number from 1 to 9 and d is a number dependent upon the valence requirements of the combined metals and may vary from compositions wherein A is molybdenum or tungsten and wherein 'a is 0 to 0.12, b is 2 to 8, c is 2 to 8 and d is to 30.

Excellent per pass conversions of the starting material to maleic anhydride in the range of 70 to 80 percent on a mole basis are obtained with the catalyst of this invention. Selectivity of the reaction for anhydride production improves markedly with an increase in molybdenum content, while catalysts with low molybdenum content produce predominantly waste materials.

Maximum conversions to maleic anhydride are obtained where the starting material is butadiene-1,3 and- /or crotonaldehyde, while conversions of the nbutylenes (butene-l and butene-2) to the anhydride are generally somewhat lower. The major by-products obtained in the oxidation of n-butylenes however are butadiene and crotonaldehyde which on recycle can be readily converted to maleic anhydride in nearly theoretical yields.

Essentially all of the product produced in this process is maleic anhydride with only minor amounts of acetic acid and acrylic acid being detected in the reaction product. Minor amounts of other carbonylic compounds in addition to crotonaldehyde are also obtained as by-products in the reaction product of our process, and suchcarbonyls as acetaldehyde, formaldehyde, furan, acrolein, and acetone have been identified by various analytical procedures including gas chromatography and mass spectroscopy. The amount of by-product obtained is dependent upon thestarting material em- :ployed with the least amount of by-product being obtained with butadiene and. crotonaldehyde.

- The process of this invention is carried out in the vapor phase in a fixed-bed or a fluid-bed reactor. The

reaction conditions may vary considerably. The process may becarried out in the temperature range of from about 650 to 850F. and preferably in the range ,of from about 700 to 800F, Below a temperature of about 650F. total conversion drops. Above about:

850F. there is increased conversion to the byproducts.

The reactor pressure in the instant process may vary from about 1 to 500 psia and preferably ranges from about 10 to psia. Molecular oxygen or a molecular oxygen-containing gas is employed in the reaction and oxygen may be present in the molar ratio of oxygen to the unsaturated organic compound of from about 1:1 to 40:1, and preferably in a ratio of 3:1 to 10:1, respectively. The use of steam in the reaction is optional and steam may be included in the feed to the reactor in amounts ranging from 0 to 50 moles of steam per mole of the organic compound. The apparent contact time in this process can vary from 0.1 to 50 seconds and preferably from about 0.5 to 10 seconds.

The method used for preparing the catalyst of this invention is critical to the process for producing maleic anhydride. The method employed departs from the usual classical procedures involving co-precipitation or impregnation techniques and preferredly involves the simple mixing of the respective metal oxides of antimony trioxide and molybdenum trioxide. The mixing of the oxides may be carried out mechanically in a blender or in a ball mill, or the respective oxides may be mixed as a slurry in water. This initial step is followed by calcination at a moderate temperature, generally not above 1000F. It is hypothesized that the bluegreen color which develops in the catalyst is the result of the reduction of molybdenum, at least in part, to a lower oxidation state in the oxidation'reduction reaction occurring between hexavalent molybdenum and trivalent antimony.

A more reproducible method for combining the two oxides comprises essentially the refluxing of an aqueous suspension of antimony trioxide with molybdenum trioxide for a period of from about 1 /2 to 16 hours and preferably from about 1 to 4 hours. The amount of water present in solution is not critical and can range from about 500 to 2000 milliliters per mole of molybdenum trioxide reacted. During this period the slurry darkens to a deep olive green color. Water is removed from the slurry by evaporation until a thick homoge' -nous material is obtained which on drying at C.

overnight emerges as a dark green solid.

In a more preferred procedure, the molybdenum trioxide in an aqueous suspension is pre-reduced in a controlled manner so that at least some of the molybdenum is reduced to a valence state below +6 before the molybdenum oxide is mixed with the antimony trioxide. A wide range of reducing agents can be employed including finely divided or colloidal metals such as molybdenum, tungsten, magnesium, aluminum or nickel, stannous ion, sulfur dioxide, organic reducing agents, hydrazine hydrate, etc. When powdered metals are employed, the amount of metal reacted ranges from 0.01 to 0.2 atoms per mole of molybdenum trioxide present. On refluxing the aqueous suspension of molybdenum trioxide with the reducing agent, at least a part of the normally insoluble molybdenum trioxide is solublized forming an intense deep blue coloration. Although preferredly the molybdenum trioxide is pre-reduced before reaction with the antimony trioxide, beneficial results are also obtained by first reacting the molybdecomponents simultaneously.

The catalyst of this invention may be supported on a carrier material such as for example, silica, zirconia, calcium stabilizedzirconia, titania, alumina, thoria, silicon carbide, clay, diatomaceous earth and the like, or it may be employed satisfactorily in an unsupported form. It a carrier is utilized it may be employed in amounts of from 5 to 95 percent by weight of the total catalyst composition.

The catalyst may be activated by calcining in air at a temperature of from about 700 to 1000F. for a period of from 1 to 5 hours. More preferredly the catalyst is activated in a mixture of steam and air at a temperature of about 800F. for from about 1 to 5 hours, followed by purging with air at a temperature of from 700 to 1000F. for about one hour. Calcination at temperatures above about l000F. has an adverse effect on the catalyst.

X-ray diffraction examination of the freshly prepared catalysts shows the presence of molybdenum trioxide, and to a lesser extent, antimony trioxide. Air activation results in the incipient formation of new, and unidentified, crystalline phases. The crystalline pattern, as revealed by X-ray diffraction, undergores further change with time on stream under process conditions such that after several hours of operation, the diffraction patterns for both starting oxides are no longer present. The new pattern indicates a highly crystalline structure of a new phase which is characteristic for highly active and selective behavior.

Preparation of the catalyst of this invention by the process described herein results in a catalyst with a composition and properties that are readily reproduced, a catalyst that has a greatly reduced bulk density, and one that displays excellent life characteristics. There are strong indications that the activity of the catalyst improves with use.

The process of this invention is further illustrated by the following specific examples, but is not to be limited by the examples presented herein. The effect on per pass conversions to maleic anhydride of catalyst composition, method of catalyst preparation, nature of the feed stock and reaction conditions employed are demonstrated by Examples 1 through 29 shown in Tables I to Ill.

The catalyst employed in the examples shown in Tables l to III were prepared according to the following procedures.

EXAMPLE 1 M00 200 grams of molybdenum trioxide (Fisher, Reagent Grade) was slurried in 1500 milliliters of distilled water and refluxed for 16 hours. The slurry was evaporated to a thick paste and dried overnight at 1 C. The resulting material was ground and screened to obtain a fraction of 20-30 mesh size. The catalyst was pre-treated in a 20-milliliter fixed-bed reactor by;

heating to 800F. in a stream of air for two hours.

EXAMPLE 2 Sb Mo O 273.5 grams of molybdenum trioxide and 29.2 grams of antimony trioxide were slurried in was olive green in color. The catalyst was ground and screened to 20-30 mesh and was pre-treated as in Example 1.

EXAMPLE 3 Sb Mo O The procedure of Example 2 was repeated except that the ratio of components was adjusted to give the composition indicated.

EXAMPLE 4 Sb ,Mo O The procedure of Example 2 was repeated except that the ratio of components was adjusted to give the composition indicated.

EXAMPLE 5 Sb Mo O The procedure of Example 2 was repeated except that the ratio of components was adjusted to give the composition indicated.

EXAMPLE 6 Sb Mo O The procedure of Example 2 was repeated except that the ratio of components was adjusted to give the composition indicated.

EXAMPLE 7 8O%(Sb Mo O )-2O%(ZrO CaO) 72 grams of M00 and 48.6 grams of Sb O were slurried in 1000 milliliters of distilled water and refluxed for 16 hours.

30.2 grams of Zircoa B were added to the above slurry, and the slurry was evaporated to a thick paste and dried overnight at C. The dried material was hard and was dark green in color. A 20-30 mesh fraction of the catalyst was pre-treated as in Example 1.

EXAMPLE 8 EXAMPLE 9 80%(Sb Mo O )-20%SiO The procedure of Example 7 was repeated except that 100.5 grams of 30% silica sol were used as the support material in place of Zircoa B.

EXAMPLE l0 Sb Mo O The procedure of Example 7 was repeated except that no supporting material was used.

EXAMPLE 1 1 The catalyst of Example 10 was activated by placing the catalyst in the reactor and heating to 8OOF. for 4 hours in an atmosphere of 90% steam and 10% air. This was followed by passing an air stream over the catalyst forzone hour at 800F. I

EXAMPLE 12 Sb4Mo O Four separate batches each containing I 143.9 grams molybdenum trioxide and 97.2 grams antimony trioxide were refluxed in 1000 mls. distilled water for 2 /2 hours, and were evaporated and dried overnight at C. The dried materials were mixed together, then ground and screened to 20/30 mesh. The resulting ma'terialwas hard and olive green in color. Pre-treatment was identical to that in Example 1.

EXAMPLE 13 The catalyst was the same as that in Example 12.

EXAMPLE l4 EXAMPLE l5 Mo Sb Mo O 72 grams of M00 0.95 grams of molybdenum metal power and 48.6 grams of Sb O were slurried in one liter of distilled water. The slurry was refluxed for 3 hours and then evaporated to a thick paste. The catalyst was then dried overnight at 1 C. and ground and screened to -30 mesh. The catalyst was pre-treated as in Example 1.

EXAMPLE [6 Mo Sb Mo O 72 grams of M00 and 48.6 grams of Sb O were slurried in one liter of distilled water. The slurry was refluxed for 3 hours. To this slurry was added 0.95 grams of molybdenum metal powder and reluxing was continued for one hour. The slurry was then evaporated, dried and screened to 20-30 mesh. The catalyst was pretreated as in Example 1.

EXAMPLE l7 Sb Mo O 288 grams of M00 and 194.3 grams of Sb O were ball milled for 24 hours. The mix was screened through a 200 mesh sieve and then pelleted.

The pellets were calcined in air for one hour at 150F. and then for 2 /2 hours at 750F.

EXAMPLE 18 Moo g Sb4Mo Oz The procedure of Example 14 was repeated.

EXAMPLE 19 W Sb Mo O The same procedure of Example 14 was employed except that 1.84 grams of tungsten metal powder were used in place of the molybdenum powder.

EXAMPLE 2O .Mg Sb Mo O The procedure of Example 14 was used except that 0.24 gram of magnesium metal powder was employed in place of the molybdenum powder.

EXAMPLE 2] Al Sb Mo O The procedure of Example 14 was employed except that 0.27 gram of aluminum metal powder was used in place of molybdenum powder.

EXAMPLE 22 Ni Sb.,Mo O The procedure of Example 14 was employed except that 0.59 gram of nickel metal powder was used in place of the molybdenum powder.

EXAMPLE 23 Sb Mo O The preparation was the same as in Example 14 except that 0.75 gram of hydrazine hydrate was used in place of the molybdenum powder.

EXAMPLE 24 Mo Sb Mo ,-O Catalyst of Example 14 was used.

EXAMPLES 25-28 Sb.,Mo O The catalyst of Example 4 was used.

The oxidation reactions summarized in Tables I to III were conducted in a 20 cc, fixed-bed, down-flow reactor consisting of a length of /2 inch stainless steel tubing equipped with a full length 4; inch axial thermowell. catalyst mesh size was through 20 to 30 mesh. The reactor was heated with a split stainless steel block furnace.

The furnace assembly was immediately adjacent to two separate insulated constant temperature enclosures. A glass saturator vessel was mounted in each enclosure and provided a means for introducing normally liquid feeds, such as water or crotonaldehyde, to the reactor feed stream.

Air was supplied to the reactor through two rotameters and one stream was mixed with the feed. The mixed stream could be directed to the second metered air feed and then to the reactor, or it could be diverted to an analyzer for the measurement of rate and composition.

The primary receiver consisted of a SOO-milliliter flask which functioned as an air condenser and most of the maleic anhydride was collected therein as a solid. The noncondensible gases passed through a water scrubber and the unabsorbed gases were vented. In certain instances an acetone scrubber was used and the scrubber liquid was analyzed directly for maleic anhydride by gas-liquid chromatography.

Product analyses of the aqueous scrubber liquid were conducted by determining total acid content by titration with standard base (0.1N sodium hydroxide) and maleic anhydride was determined by gravimetric precipitation of barium maleate. The scrubber liquid which contained carbonyl products such as acetaldehyde, furan, acrolein, methyl ethyl ketone, crotonaldehyde and acetone was analyzed by gas chromatography using a n-propanol internal standard and a three foot Poropak QS column in a F & M 810 Research Chromatograph. The analyses of the liquid products were conducted by comparing the response of the unknown sample with that of a standard.

The gravimetric method for analyzing maleic anhydride consisted of mixing 25 milliliters of the scrubber solution with 20 milliliters of a solution of 5% BaCl.2- H 0 and adding concentrated ammonium hydroxide to obtain a phenolphthalein reaction. The solution was then diluted to milliliters with absolute alcohol. The filitered precipitate was dried at l 10C. for 2 to 3 hours and the maleic anhydride was calculated as barium maleate monohydrate, according to the method described in J. Am. Chem. Soc. 57, 1390, 1935.

In the examples given in Tables I to I11, molar percent per pass conversion to maleic anhydride is defined as follows:

on a single pass of the starting material over the catalyst,

Grams of carbon as total acid obtained The experimental examples summarized in Table 1 using butene-2 as the feed illustrate the effect of vary ing the ratio of antimony to molybdenum in the catalyst composition, the use of a carrier and the effect of catalyst activation. The conversions obtained with the various catalyst compositions shown in Examples 1 to 6 indieate that a broad composition range of antimony oxide to molybdenum oxide can be employed and that only at the extremes of the composition range does the activity for producing maleic anhydride decline.

Examples 7 to 9 indicate that the active catalyst may be effectively deposited on various support materials, and the beneficial effect of activating the catalyst with steam is indicated in Example 1 l.

The effect on catalytic acitivity of pre-reducing the molybdenum trioxide with a reducing agent, and the preparational sequence of adding the reducing agent during the preparation of the catalyst are shown by the examples in Table ll employing butadiene as the feed. The improvement in activity by adding powdered molybdenum metal to the catalyst either before, during, or subsequent to the reaction of molybdenum trioxide with the antimony trioxide is shown in Examples 14 through 16. An increase in activity is also observed with other reducing agents incorporated into the catalyst such as tungsten, magnesium, aluminum, nickel and hydrazine (Examples 19 through 23). The im provement in catalytic activity obtained with a catalyst prepared by mixing the oxide components in an aqueous slurry as compared with dry-blending is shown by comparing Examples 12 and 13 with Example 17.

The effect of process variables on per pass conversion utilizing various feed stocks is shown by various examples in Tables I to Ill. The effect of employing reaction temperature below 700F. is illustrated with crotonaldehyde in Examples 25 to 28 in Table II]. These examples indicate that conversions to maleic anhydride 1() drop sharply at a reaction temperature of about 650F. Although maximum conversions to maleic anhydride are obtained at a temperature of about 750F. substantial levels of conversions are obtained at temperatures as high as 850F. Molar ratios of feed to air varying from 1:25 to 1:75 are also indicated in these same examples.

LIFE TEST EXPERIMENTS The excellent life characteristics of the catalyst of this process was demonstrated for a period of about 2 months, employing the catalyst of Example 14 and butadiene as the feed. After this period of time the total amount of maleic anhydride produced increased from the initial per pass conversion of 72.4 percent to a conversion of 74.7 percent. Surprisingly the catalyst of this invention retains its activity through extremes in operating conditions, as for example, the use of very low air ratios and high hydrocarbon rates. These adverse conditions were maintained for overnight periods, followed by periods of normal operating conditions. After several cycles of this type of operation a final per pass conversion of butadiene to maleic anhydride of 76.8 percent was obtained as compared with a 75.3 percent conversion initially.

Table Conversions to Maleic Anhydride Feed: Butene-2 Reactor: 20 cc Fixed-Bed Mole 7:

v Per Pass Conversions to Bath Molar Feed Ratio C.T. Total Maleic Selectivity to Example Temp.(F.) HC Air (Sec.) WWH Acid Anhydride Maleic Anhydride (Z) EFFECT OF CATALYST COMPOSlTlON 1 750 1 26 3.2 0.031 1.2 Essentially zero 2 800 1 29 3.1 19.9 18.8 94.5

EFFECT OF CATALYST SUPPORT 7 EFFECT OF CATALYST ACTlVATlON Table I! Feed: Butadiene Reactor: 20 cc Fixed-Bed I Mole Molar Feed Ratio Per Pass Conversions to Bath C.T. Total Maleic Example Temp F.) HC Air H O (Sec.) WWH Acid Anhydride EFFECT OF CATALYST PREPARATION 12 700 l 27 3.2 0.024 58.0 54.5 13 750 l 26 3.0 0.025 58.9 57.3 14 700 1 33 3.1 0.066 77.3 76.6 15 700 l 33 3.1 0.021 70.1 70.9 16 700 l 30 3.1 0.023 69.9 64.5 17 725 1 30 2.2 47.0 18 700 l 33 3.2 0.060 77.6" 74.3

Table II Continued perature in the range of from about 650F. to 850F., under a pressure of from about 1 to 500 psi, and wherein the molar ratio of oxygen to the organic compound is in the range of from about l:l to 40:1, respectively, said catalyst having the formula:

u b c ll wherein A is a member selected from the group consist- Mole 7r Molar Feed Ratio Per Pass Conversions to Bath C.T. Total Malcic Example Temp.( F.) HC Air H2O (Sec. WWH Acid Anhydride EFFECT OF PROCESS STEAM 24 700 1 32 17 2.1 0.067 80.7 70.1

Table III Conversions to Maleic Anhydride Feed: crotonaldehyde Reactor: 20 cc Fixed-Bed Mole Molar Feed Ratio Per Pass Conversions to Bath C.T. Total Maleic Example Temp.(F.) HC Air N2 (See) WWH Acid Anhydride 29 Similar results were obtained with furan as the starting material We claim: 30 the molybdenum in the catalyst is at a valence state 1. A process for producing maleic anhydride com-. below +6. prising contacting a mixture of an unsaturated organic 2. The process in claim 1 wherein the catalyst is supcompound selected from the group consisting of nported on a carrier material selected from the group butylenes, butadiene-l,3, crotonaldehyde and furan consisting of zirconia, calcium-stabilized zirconia, siland an oxygen-containing gas with a catalyst at a temica, titania, alumina, thoria, silicon carbide, clay and diatomaceous earth.

3. The process in claim 1 wherein there is included in the mixture from O to moles of steam per mole of the organic compound.

4. The process in claim 1 wherein the apparent contact time is from 0.1 to 50 seconds.

5. The process in claim 4 wherein the organic compound is butadiene.

6. The process in claim 5 wherein A in the catalyst formula is molybdenum.

7. The process in claim 5 wherein A in the catalyst formula is tungsten.

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION PATENT NO. 3,907, 83 1 DATED September 23, 1975 N EN OR( 1 Ernest C. Milberger, Serge R. Dolhyj & Harley Hardman It is certified that error appears in the above-identified patent and that said Letters Patent are hereby corrected as shown below:

Column 5: Example 16, line 5, "reluxing" should be refluxing Signed and Scaled this Fourth Day Of January 1977 [SEAL] Attest:

RUTH C. MASON C. MARSHALL DANN Arresting Officer Commissioner ofParents and Trademarks

Claims (7)

1. A PROCESS FOR PRODUCING MALEIC ANTHDRIDE COMPRISING CONTACTING A MIXTURE OF AN UNSATURATED ORGANIC COMPOUND SELECTED FROM THE GROUP CONSISTING OF N-BUTYLENE, BUTADIENE1,3, CROTONALDEHYDE AND FURAN AND AN OXYGEN-CONTAINING GAS WITH A CATALYST AT A TEMPERATURE IN THE RANGE OF FROM ABOUT 650*F. TO 850*F., UNDER A PRESSURE OF FROM ABOUT 1 TO 500 PSI, AND WHEREIN THE MOLAR RATIO OF OXYGEN TO THE ORGANIC COMPOUND IS IN THE RANGE OF FROM ABOUT 1:1 TO 40:1, RESPECTIVELY, SAID CATALYST HAVING THE FORMULA:

2. The process in claim 1 wherein the catalyst is supported on a carrier material selected from the group consisting of zirconia, calcium-stabilized zirconia, silica, titania, alumina, thoria, silicon carbide, clay and diatomaceous earth.

3. The process in claim 1 wherein there is included in the mixture from 0 to 50 moles of steam per mole of the organic compound.

4. The process in claim 1 wherein the apparent contact time is from 0.1 to 50 seconds.

5. The process in claim 4 wherein the organic compound is butadiene.

6. The process in claim 5 wherein A in the catalyst formula is molybdenum.

7. The process in claim 5 wherein A in the catalyst formula is tungsten.