CA1332074C

CA1332074C - Surge protection device

Info

Publication number: CA1332074C
Application number: CA000600496A
Authority: CA
Inventors: Benny H. Lee
Original assignee: World Products Inc
Current assignee: World Products Inc
Priority date: 1988-08-29
Filing date: 1989-05-24
Publication date: 1994-09-20
Anticipated expiration: 2011-09-20
Also published as: US4901183A; WO1990002431A1; KR900702615A; JPH04500298A; EP0430949A1

Abstract

SURGE PROTECTION DEVICE
Abstract of the Disclosure A surge or transient protection circuit is described which operates in an immediate fail-safe mode of failure. If an incoming transient exceeds the tran-sient absorption capacity of the circuit, precision fast-blow fuses are immediately opened to remove current from the load to prevent damage to the equipment connected to the transient suppression circuit and to indicate to the user that the transient suppression abi-lities of this circuit have been damaged. The transient suppression circuit uses silicon transient voltage suppressor components to absorb the fast-rising edge of transients and also uses slower-acting MOV transient absorption devices for the bulk of the overvoltage tran-sient power. Upon short-circuit failure of any of the suppressor components, the excessive current draw pro-duced thereby results in blowing of the fast-blow fuses.

Description

SURGE PROTECTION DEVICE

Field of the Invention The present invention relates to power line protection devices and in particular to AC power line surye and transient protection, RFI, EMI and ESD protec-tion devices.
.: .
Background of the Invention A wide variety of modern commercial and con-sumer electronics employ microchip technology which is particularly sensitive to power line transients or surges, RFI (radio frequency interference), EMI ~;~
; (electromagnetic interference) and ESD (electrostatic ~;
discharge). Such devices as computers, stereos, televi-sions, radios and the like can all be affected if not ` 15 seriously damaged by unfiltered, unprotected or generally "dirty" AC power.
Of these four general types of power line disturbances, power surges or transients are by far the most damaging. These surges are found on power lines 20 from a wide variety o~ sources, such as lightning, power -company switching, collapsing electric fields when electric motors are shut down, surges when electric motors are started, ~parking between power lines, arcing between opening and closing relay contacts, and the like. These voltage surges of 400V or more can find their way into sensitive microchip technology electro~
nics and damage or destroy circuitry. Thus, at a mini-mum, surge protection is extremely important for commercial or consumer electronics, and especially ~ 30 ~

:~ :
: ' ' -2- l 332074 important for personal computing systems which can suffer data dropout and circ~lit failures in the pre~ence of power lines surge~.
A wide variety of prior art surge or transient protection and surge or transient suppression devices are available for removing or dampening offending power line surges and transients in order to protact the consumer electronic~ connected thereto. Many of these prior art transient or surge ~uppression devices are typically tested to specifications produced by, for example, the In~titute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE), Underwriters Laboratories (UL1449 and UL1283), the Federal Communications Commission tFCC) or -the Con~ultant Committee, International Telegraph and Telephone (CCITT). The mo~t common among these standards is the IEEE Standard 5~7 (ANSI C62.41-1981).
The portion of this technical specification which supplies to indoor applications describes transient conditions occurr~ng in low voltage (less than 600V) AC
power circuits in which the transients exceed twice the `~
peak operating vol~age with durations ranging from a ~`
fraction o~ a microsecond to a milli~econd and ;~
originating primarily from system switching and -~
lightening effects. This standard has been promulgated to evaluate the survival capability of equipment ....
connected to power circuits as described in ~L1449. In ~
testing against this standard, many of the pr;or art ~-surge protection devices combine transient suppression components with additional componentq to perform RFI and EMI filtering which may also be réquired to comply with FCC standards. `~
To survive the impulse characteristics of IEEE -~
587-1981 for indoor applications and to meet the stan-''~' ,.~.

--3-- 7 3 3 2 ~ 7 ~ !

dards of UL1449 (and become listed by UL), prior art surge protection devices are typically designed to shunt the offending surge current and thus limit the over-voltage portion of the transient to the neutral or return line, thus creating a momentary low-impedance path between the power line and the return path. The clamping device must be designed to operate above a cer-tain voltage threshold and must be capable of withstanding the current which is momentarily shunted to ground. Typical components used in prior art devices to ~` clamp or limit the overvoltage portions of transients - have been gas-filled spark gap surge arrestors, MOV's (metal oxide varistors) available from Sanken Electric, GE and other vendors, and silicon transient voltage suppressors such as the TVS 1.5KE series devices available from World Products Inc., the TransZorb~ tran- ~ ;
sient voltage suppressor devices available from General Semiconductor Industries, Inc., and other vendors.
~; These aforementioned shunt or clamping electronic devi-ces are designed to withstand a plurality of overvoltage transients and safely shunt them to ground, thus pro~
tecting the device to which they are attached.
A problem with the prior art surge protection devices is when the shunt or clamp electronic components ~ i .
fail during repeated overvoltage transients. All of the aforementioned transient suppression devices can fail "open" (although they will momentarily fail "closed"), which in effect removes them from the circuit and leaves ~ the power line and the devices connected thereto unpro-,~, ; 30 tlected from subsequent power line surges. To remedy ~
~his situation, prior art power line surge protection -devices have been designed such that a monitor light or ~ ' - 4 - 1332074 ; ;

LED indicator is used to indicate that the surge suppression devices are still operating properly.
Should the power line surge protection devices fail, the indicator light will be extinguished, indicating to the user tllat the power line protection has been lost. A
further problem with the prior art surge protection devices and their associated indicator lights is that the indicators are not always readily accessible or visible by the user. The surge protection devices are 10 often located near a wall outlet or on the floor under a -des~. The location of these suppressor devices inhibits the user or owner in identifying a failed condition on the surge or transient suppression device. Thus, pro~
tection may be lost and go unnoticed for quite some ;
time, leaving the electronic equipment which is attached to the failed surye protector open to damage by power line surges. ;
To alleviate this problem, some prior art i~
surge protection devices interrupt the power upon the ~j 20 failure of the transient suppression components. An example of a power line transient surge suppressor which ~ ;~
interrupts power in this fashion is U. S. Patent No.
4,587,588. The device described in this patent senses the failure of a transient suppression component and `-~
removes power from the load by using a thermal cutout which actuates within a few minutes of the failure of one of the surge suppression components of the device.
However, the delay between the failure of a surge suppression device and the opening of the thermal cutout ~ `
leaves the load vulnerable to a second and subsequent !~ . !
transient which may then damage the equipment connected to the transient suppression device. ~;

.

.. ...
,'","'''''".
'..' `'''"

"".,`'' _ 5 _ 1 3 3 2 0 7 4 There therefore is a need in the prior art for a transient or surge protection device which disconnects power from the load lmmediately upon the failure of any of the transient suppression components of the device.

Summary of the Inve_tion To alleviate the problems of the prior art indicated above and to provide other advantages and benefits which will be readily recognized to those skilled in the art upon reading and understanding the present specification, the present invention describes a power line protection circuit which has an immediate fail-safe mode of operation. If the transient suppression electronic components within the present invention fail, they will fail shorted long enough to allow the entire circuit to interrupt power from the electronic components and equipment attached to the pre-sent invention immediately upon sensing the failure. In such a failure mode, the user is alerted to the failure of the surge protection devices due to the fact that the equipment is disconnected from the power line, thus pre-venting any damage to the equipment due to unfiltered transients or surges.
The preferred embodiment of the present inven-tion describes a three-line, four-stage surge protection device which also provides RFI and EMI filtering. The ~ ~ primary stage of the-present invention consists of fast-`~; blow finely calibrated iuses connected between the power line and the remaining stages of the present invention.
,~ j 30 The second stage, connected in series with the first stage, consists of MOV devices to provide three-line ~'~ heavy current surge protection in either common mode or ~-~ , ~

- 6 - I 332074 ~

differential mode. The third stage of the present invention i5 connected in series with the second stage and serves the double purpose of isolating the second ~;
and fourth stages of the present invention and providing RFI and EMI limiting through an LC combination forming a filter circuit. The fourth stage of the present inven-tion is connected between the third stage and the electronic equipment which is to be protected, and con-, -SiStS of bidirectional silicon transient voltage '~
suppression devices for high-speed clamping of the first rising edge of the incoming surge~
In operation, the present invention will sense and begin to clamp the wavefront of an incoming over-voltage transient through the bidirectional silicon clamp devices. The heavier portion of the current found later in time in the,transient is then clamped by the;,'~
slower reacting yet heavier current capacity MOV clamp,~
devices. While both the silicon transient voltage suppression devices and MOV transient suppression devi~
20 ces are clamping an overvoltage condition, a high amount;~
o~ instantaneous power is being shunted or diverted by the present invention. If this amount of power exceeds,'~
the capacity of any of the transient absorption com~
, ~ ponents of the present invention, the finely calibrated '~ ',' 25 fuses will open due to the increased current demand of',, '',', the shorted MOV or shorted silicon transient voltage suppression (TVS) devices. The opening of one or more of the finely calibrated fuses will interrupt power from ', the power line and remove the electronic equipment from ,/,, 30 h,arm. , ,~
,,:'".

,'':

'' .~:, ',',~ ~:

`~ 1 33207~

_ief Descriptlon of the Drawing The Figure shows tle preierred embodiment of the present invention for a single-phase 120VAC line surge suppressor application.

~etailed Description of the . . .
Preferred Embodiment In the following detailed description of the preferred em~odiment, reference is made to the accom-panying drawing which forms a part hereof and in which is shown by way of illustration a specific embodiment in which the present invention may be practiced. This pre-ferred embodiment is described in sufficient detail to enable those s~illed ln the art to practice the inven-tion, and it is to be understood that other embodiments may be utilized and that structural or electrical changes may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. The following detailed description is, therefore, not to be taken in a limiting sense, and the scope of the present invention is defined by the appended claims. ~;
The preferred embodiment of the present inven-tion is designed to be connected between an AC power ~;~ 25 line supplying, for example, 120-volt, 60-cycle current in the North American Standard, and a load which requires surge or transient protection, such as computer equipment. The line connection is shown to the left of ;~
the Figure, with the load connection shown to the right.
, 30 The line connection designated H refers to the hot side of a 120V single-phase circuit, while the N stands for the neutral or return current path. The line connector .~ .
'.

:
.

~-~ 1 33207~

designated G is for the earth or ground connection.
Stage 1 of the surge protector circuit is comprised of fuses Fl, F2 and capacitor Cl. Capacitor Cl is used for the reduction of common mode noise between the hot and neutral lines and serves to slow the fast rise of an incoming transient. Capacitor Cl is in the preferred embodiment a safety rated RFI capacitor having a value of 0.l microfarad.
The fuses selected in the preferred embodiment of the present invention are fast-blow, high precision fuses rated at 12.0 Amperes available from Schurter, Inc. of Petaluma, California, part No. 001.1016, the ~
amperagei selected based upon the requirements of the ~;,, user. These fuses are designed to have a precise 15 current fusing point in response to near-instantaneous ;~
(less than or equal to 20 milliseconds) overcurrent con-ditions produced by the shorting of the TVS or MOV to provide a serial fail-safe OPEN. The fuses are designed to open in the event of excess current being shunted by any of the parallel protection components of the later stages. The fuses are designed to be internal to the circuit and not replaceable by the user. External fuses '~
or circuit breakers at a similar or lower rating of fuses Fl, F2 would be used for moderate over-current ;25 protection such as a short circuit on the load side or a constant overcurrent draw on the load side. Should a user of the present invention be allowed to replace fuses Fl, F2, chances are that the incorrect size and ~;
type of fuse may be used, making the present circuit ineffective for protecting the components connected to the load. Since the TVS devices fail shorted, the replacement fuses for Fl, F2 would blow OPEN again until '' -: , :` ~
9 - 1 33~74 the shorted TVS device was replaced. For this reason, the fuses are contained inside a cabinet inaccessible to the outside and the circuit must be repaired or replaced by an authorized repair service person.
Stage two protection of the present invention consists of MOV (Metal Oxide Varistor) components Ml, M2 and M3. Ml is connected between the hot and neutral lines, M2 lS connected between the neutral and ground lines, and M3 is connected between the hot and ground lines. This provides three-line protection for tran-sient suppression from a transient between any two of the three lines. MOV devices are classified as nonli-near resistors or voltage dependen~ resistors. The MOV
device is a sintered ceramic material between two con-ductors consisting of zinc oxide as a primary ingredient along with several other metal oxide additives. The ~;
clamping time of an MOV device is typically in the ~-~
20-nanosecond range. The clamping voltage is selected by the construction of the device for a fixed amount of current. At increasing levels of current, the clamping voltage of an MOV increases. The MOV devices used in the preferred embodiment of the present invention are designed for diverting large amounts of current and carrying the brunt of force behind an incoming tran-sient. They are, in the preferred embodiment, part No.
SNRA-130K20 available from World Products~ Inc. of ~`~
Sonoma, CA, and are selected to have a nominal operating voltage of 130 volts RMS.
Stage three of the present invention shown in ~he Figure consists of inductors Ll and L2 and capaci-tors C2 and C3. The inductors and capacitors form an LC
filter circuit to provide EMI and RFI protection while -~

'`~'' lo - 1 332074 isolating stage two from stage four of the Figure. The inductors Ll, L2 also serve as delay line or isolation devices when the present invention is subjected to a transient. The inductors serve to delay the full 5 current so the TVS devices Tl-T3 clamp only a limited ~;
amount of current corresponding to the oncoming wavefront of the transient. Approximately 20 nS after the TVS devices conduct to divert current, the MOV will begin conducting to shunt the remainder of the transient 10 wave. In the preferred embodiment, inductors Ll and L2 ,; -are 91-microhenry inductors formed by winding 31 turns of 13 A~G wire on a powdered iron core, part No.
T157-40 available from Micro Metal of San Diego, California. Capacitors C2 and C3 are in the preferred embodiment 0.0022-microfarad.
Stage four of the present invention shown in the Figure consists of silicon transient voltage suppressors T1, T2 and T3, which in the preferred embo-diment are TVS (transient voltage suppression) diode devices also available from World Products, Inc~ TVS
device T1 is connected between the hot and neutral lines, T2 is connected between the neutral and ground lines, and T3 is connected between the hot and ground llnes. This provides additional three-line pro~ection ~; 25 for transient suppression for a transient between any two of the three lines. ~
The silicon transient suppressors such as the ;
TVS type are characterized by their sharp avalanche characteristics, high surge handling capabilites and sub-nanosecond response time to transients. These types of transient suppression devices can handle the leading edge of a fast-rising surge to clamp the front of that ' ' surge to a ground or return path. Devices Tl-T3, however, cannot divert as high a current capacity as that of MOV devices Ml-M3 (which are slower reacting but can divert higher currents without destruction). In the preferred embodiment of the present invention, the tran-sient voltage suppression devices Tl-T3 are 200-volt breakdown devices, while the MOV devices are 130-volt RMS breakdown. Devices Tl-T3 in the preferred embodi-ment are part No. l.SKE200CA available from World 10 Products, Inc. and other second-source vendors. The ;
output of stage four is connected to the load device which reguires surge protection.
In operation, an incoming transient between any two of the three lines on the LINE side of the Figure enters the circuit through fuses Fl or F2 or;
both. The leading edge of a fast-rising transient will be damped somewhat by the absorbing capacity of capaci-tor Cl. Very fast pulse edges may pass beyond capacitor ~Cl and are attenuated and delayed by inductors Ll or L2 -~20 or both. Some of these very fast pulse edges, however, ~ ~-may pass inductors Ll or L2 due to parasitic stray capa-citances and find their way to stage four of the cir-cuit. In this stage, silicon transient voltage suppressor devices Tl-T3 react in a sub-nanosecond time to absorb the leading edges of any transi~nts. Thus, ~,. .. ~ , transient voltage suppression devices Tl-T3 are the first clamp or shunt devices to conduct the leading wavefront of the transient.
`~ Silicon transient voltage suppression devices Tl-T3 cannot in all cases divert all the power of an incoming transient. Shortly after the clamp devices of stage four begin conducting (typically 20 nS), the MOV

:~ ~ "'' .;
; ;;

- 12 - 133~074 devices of stage two will begin conducting to clamp the majority of the incoming current of the overvoltage transient. If, however, the voltage transient contains suf~icient power to exceed the capacities of the shunt or clamp devices of either stage two or four, the MOV or TVS devices will fail in a shorted condition which in turn will cause an instantaneous or near-instantaneous current rise through the fuses of stage one. If the current exceeds the rated value of fuses F1 or F2, one or the other of the fuses will open, quickly interrupting power to the load. In this fashion, the load is protected from transients which have the capa-city to exceed the transient absorption capacity of the surge protection circuit of the Figure shown. Since the fuses Fl, F2 interrupt power immediately upon failure of any of the MOV or TVS devices, second or subsequent transients following closely behind the first transient will not pass to the equipment connected to the LOAD
side of the present invention.
Those skilled in the art will readily recognize that the capacitive elements are interchangeable in their position and the order is not intended to be limiting. The selection of the com-ponents of the preferred embodiment is intended to construct a device which conforms to the UL1449 standard ;~ and is rated for 15 A max (or other current ratings) at 50-400 Hz steady state current. -~;
While the present invention has been described -in connection with the preferred embodiment thereof, it will be understood that many modifications, such as the use of circuit breakers, manual ON/OFF switches, power indicators, failure indicators and the li~e, will be ' ~:
..;

- 13 - l 33 2 07~

readily apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art, and this application is intended to cover any adap-tations or variations thereof. Therefore, it is mani-festly intended that this invention be limited only by 5 the claims and the equivalents thereof. ~

~; ~ ~ "''"' `~ ' '~ '~` , o ~'~ ' ' "'',' ,~'',.

Claims

1. A fail-safe voltage surge protection circuit for transient protection of AC lines, comprising:
input means having a hot line, a neutral line and a ground line for receiving power from an AC
supply line;
output means having a hot line, a neutral line and a ground line for supplying said power to a load:
a first MOV connected between the hot line and neutral line of said input means, a second MOV
connected between the neutral line and the ground line of said input means and a third MOV
connected between the hot line and the ground line of the input means;
a first silicon transient suppressor connected between the hot line and neutral line of said output means, a second silicon transient suppressor connected between the neutral line and the ground line of said output means and a third silicon transient suppressor connected between the hot line and the ground line of the output means;
a first inductor connected between the hot line of said input means and the hot line of said output means, and a second inductor connected between the neutral line of said input means and the neutral line of said output means; first fuse means having a response time of less than 20 milliseconds at a precise current level connected in series in said hot line of said input means for fail-safe removal of said power from said load if any of said first MOV, third MOV, first silicon transient suppressor or third silicon transient suppressor fail shorted;
second fuse means having a response time of less than 20 milliseconds at a precise current level connected in series in said neutral line of said input means for fail-safe removal of said power from said load if any of said first MOV, second MOV, first silicon transient suppressor or second silicon transient suppressor fail shorted; and said ground line of said input means connected to said ground line of said output means.

2. A fail-safe voltage surge protection circuit for transient protection of AC line, comprising:
input means having a hot line, a neutral line and a ground line for receiving power from an AC supply line;
output means having a hot line, a neutral line and a ground line for supplying said power to a load:
a first MOV connected between the hot line and neutral line of said input means, a second MOV
connected between the neutral line and the ground line of said input means and a third MOV
connected between the hot line and the ground line of the input means;
a first silicon transient suppressor connected between the hot line and neutral line of said output means, a second silicon transient suppressor connected between the neutral line and the ground line of said output means and a third silicon transient suppressor connected between the hot line and the ground line of the output means;
a first inductor connected between the hot line of said input means and the hot line of said output means, and a second inductor connected between the neutral line of said input means and the neutral line of said output means;
fuse means having a response time of less than 20 milliseconds at a precise current level connected in series in said hot line of said input means for fail-safe removal of said power from said load if any of first MOV, third MOV, first silicon transient suppressor or third silicon transient suppressor fail shorted; and said ground line of said input means connected to said ground line of said output means.